It's incredible to come across a list like this and agree with almost every point. Hell, I still fire up Tony Hawk 2 and 3 just for the sheer hell of it. The only two I didn't agree with were Mass Effect and Terarria. I just couldn't get into those.
Games that aren't on this list that I replay a lot are: Vampire: The Masquerade: Bloodlines, FreQuency, TES: Skyrim, the Dawn of War series (mainly Dark Crusade and Soulstorm), Star Wars Jedi Knight: Jedi Academy, Prince of Persia (2008), Curse of Monkey Island, GTA: San Andreas, Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon, Dungeon Siege, Bionic Commando (2009), Beyond Good & Evil, Need For Speed: Underground 1 + 2, and Folklore.
Then again, my tastes are all over the place.