As much as I liked most of the games on this list(that I've played), Bloodborne would be my top choice. Particularly because Bloodborne is both an excellant game and it's the only SOULS game to have it's MP(Co-op especially and messages) locked behind the PS+ paywall, which still boggles my mind. It's even wierder because I detest the DS invasion mechanic with a burning passion, but the fact that what was a previously free feature is something that now requires ponying up for a subscription service feels like horseshit.