Happened to me with Deus Ex 2. All the bitching and moaning of the retard crowd got to me and I was convinced it was rubbish without even trying it. When I decided to give it a go, I discovered one of the best cyberpunk stories I've ever seen (that includes books). Thief Deadly Shadows as well. Again with the bitching and moaning, "ohhh the previous games are way better, this sucks". After playing it, I consider it the best in the series. Yes, some of the levels are smaller than Thief 2, but that's the extent of it really, Deadly Shadows had a fully fleshed out story instead of the ramblings of the previous games, and it achieved brilliance in its gameplay and mission design so frequently that I couldn't believe it, and has at least a dozen moments that left a permanent impression on my mind.