A report on Somali Pirates

Recommended Videos

ryai458

New member
Oct 20, 2008
1,493
0
0
This is a report I did for my school.

Somali Pirates



Piracy has been around since the earliest times. Since the beginning of the civil war in Somali in the 1990?s piracy there has been a threat to international shipping. Due to increased activity during the last several years many countries have started patrolling the waters off the coast of Somali. Most of the pirates are between the ages of 20-35 years old. They are sometimes former fishermen who say that illegal fishing is threatening their livelihood. Warlords use pirates to get the ransoms, and then split the money, also giving the pirates weapons and supplies as payment.

In the 12 months before November 08 Somali pirates have received over 150 million US dollars in ransoms and deals. On October 7th, 2008 the United Nations enacted Resolution 1838. This resolution stated that countries with vessels in the pirated area would help combat the threat. The UN Security Council also called for a peacekeeping force. Which hasn?t happened yet, although with all the different countries ships already there it wouldn?t make a large difference. There is a four ship NATO task force off the coasts of Somalia patrolling. They have had successes in stopping hijackings. With the continued attacks on shipping there might have to be more military action. America has been stepping up and sending ships and personnel to Somali. They don?t have very effective intelligence, unfortunately, in Somali or surrounding countries. Russia has been sending more ships to Somali, specifically the Horn of Africa. America is saying that military action is not the key, and that economic help should bolster legal professions making less people commit crimes. This would probably make it so there are less pirates but America would have to spend billions to bolster Somalia?s economy. The Russian navy has had a lot of success stop several hijackings and capturing a pirate mother ship. These mother ships are large fishing boats that they have stolen that they used to bring their small zodiacs out into the ocean where the commercial shipping is. The Indian navy has been off the coast of Somalia for several years trying to keep the pirates at bay unfortunately they don?t have many ships. One of their frigates recently sunk a pirates ship after coming under fire from them.


The Russians have established a strong military front in Somalia. With ships working with other countries repelling attacks. A Russian frigate worked along with a British frigate to stop a group of pirates from hijacking a tanker. They used helicopters to scare off the pirates although we don?t know if shots were fired at the pirates. An American ship also was chased for about an hour and was fired upon but was able to evade.

Over the last year attacks have actually increased even with more ships defending the coasts. The groups of pirates have made the Gulf of Aden the most dangerous shipping lane in the world. Basic economics makes it obvious that since more attacks are occurring the pirates must be making a profit. NATO and Russia have proposed actually dealing with the prisoners that they capture. Canada is promoting just releasing them after detaining them for a short time, catch and release. If companies would allow more military action instead of paying them off less pirates would be will to risk there lives. If the economy in Somalia is improved and the world?s military takes a more aggressive approach then the threat of pirates would subside.

This crisis has been going on since 1990s but has just come into the public eye, because of recent attacks on larger tankers and even an attempt on a cruise ship. If the world governments don?t take a stronger approach with dealing with the pirates it will only get worse. If it gets much worse the UN or NATO might have to start sending troops onto the ground. To find there bases and to make a more permanent solution. With no main government in Somalia a ground solution may be necessary.

Information for this report was located at:
Wikipedia.org
Washington Post
CNN.com
BBC News


Well thats all I hope it was enjoyable and enlightened you, I know this is probably a wrong time to post this but im getting offline tonight so I thought I would let the good people at the Escapist have a good (or bad) read.
 

ryai458

New member
Oct 20, 2008
1,493
0
0
I will see you all tomorrow even though this probably wont get off the ground.
 

Marv21

New member
Jan 1, 2009
957
0
0
Thanks for the info!


But how to solve this probelm is a good one!.....if we just kill the pirate, what would that do? And if we just hand somlia money to fix itself it would cost us a pretty penny and tell all the other African Countries that all they need to get fixed up is to indirectly hurt other nations through trade!

Because if we just kill them, it would be overly brutal, yet providing a point!

If we give them cash, then we get more poor!

Quote/reply to my question I do want to hear your answers!
 

Bibliomancer

New member
Apr 17, 2009
414
0
0
In my political science class, I suggested that we warn the civilians out of the ports, then burn the ports to the ground. My teacher said that while it would work, other countries might think that it was too harsh a response.
 

13lackfriday

New member
Feb 10, 2009
660
0
0
I'm getting really sick of all these stories of self-important, untrained hoodlums making off with millions simply by amassing a collection of small arms and boarding huge cargo ships with millions in goods onboard, that simply cannot outrun even their tiny, rickety motor boats.

I was in support of pretty much any action suggested.
I know Blackwater's got a shit reputation after that atrocity in Iraq, but hell, at least put them to use on the seas, where at least the enemy is visible.
Commissioning privateers? Hell yeah! Fight fire with fire!

Quite frankly, I don't think this whole pirating issue is worth the coverage it's getting.
It could be very easily and quickly resolved: We need to go Barbary Coast on their collective asses.
 

Perticular Elk

New member
Jul 9, 2008
104
0
0
I think we have two options. Either arm the crew or eradicate the pirate strongholds. Both of these ideas make sense ( at least to rational people).
 

Agayek

Ravenous Gormandizer
Oct 23, 2008
5,175
0
0
Perticular Elk said:
I think we have two options. Either arm the crew or eradicate the pirate strongholds. Both of these ideas make sense ( at least to rational people).
Agreed. I'm more in favor of the first option though, that way there is minimal risk of collateral damage.
 

Internet Kraken

Animalia Mollusca Cephalopada
Mar 18, 2009
6,915
0
0
Glerken said:
Your professor actually let you use Wikipedia as a source?
To be fair, the quality of Wikipedia articles have increased dramatically.

Still, it looks more professional if you use the sources Wikipedia cites rather than Wikipedia itself.
 

Jakkal

New member
Apr 21, 2009
76
0
0
Bibliomancer said:
In my political science class, I suggested that we warn the civilians out of the ports, then burn the ports to the ground. My teacher said that while it would work, other countries might think that it was too harsh a response.
Great idea! I think they had it coming to them, but what if the pirates left with the civilians? And did anyone hear about the pirates that mistook a French warship for a cargo ship, lol!
 

Xrysthos

New member
Apr 13, 2009
401
0
0
The pirates are just a symptom of many problems arising in Africa. I belive that through funding governments and providing their national budgets with aid should cease. We are just prolonging the problem. Dependency on the extra cash from foreign aid will increase, and once we cannot continiue increasing the funds, or for some reason have to stop providing them, the economy will collapse. The longer we wait, the harder it will be. The only humane thing to do is to stop providing this humanitarian care, which honestly doesn't do much good in the long run, and let the countries stabilise themselves. It might be messy, but it's the only option for long term survival. Naturally, providing help with things such as basic healthcare, clean water and schools are a good thing, but directly funding governments is a terrible idea. It sounds harsh and cynical, and it is, but drastic change is needed to ensure the future survival and political stability of Africa.
 

sneakypenguin

Elite Member
Legacy
Jul 31, 2008
2,804
0
41
Country
usa
This works

Israeli ex soldiers [http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1081385.html]

EDIT: Don't you need a works cited page thats more than, or is that just how you posted it here.
WP
WIki
etc
etc
 

Perticular Elk

New member
Jul 9, 2008
104
0
0
Xrysthos said:
The pirates are just a symptom of many problems arising in Africa. I belive that through funding governments and providing their national budgets with aid should cease. We are just prolonging the problem. Dependency on the extra cash from foreign aid will increase, and once we cannot continiue increasing the funds, or for some reason have to stop providing them, the economy will collapse. The longer we wait, the harder it will be. The only humane thing to do is to stop providing this humanitarian care, which honestly doesn't do much good in the long run, and let the countries stabilise themselves. It might be messy, but it's the only option for long term survival. Naturally, providing help with things such as basic healthcare, clean water and schools are a good thing, but directly funding governments is a terrible idea. It sounds harsh and cynical, and it is, but drastic change is needed to ensure the future survival and political stability of Africa.
I have always been perplexed with the current system of international welfare. What Africa needs is foreign investment from companies and venture capitalists. Once industry permeates, their Gov't can tax the profit, which will be more dependable then many nationalized commodities system they have. Our states would benefit from the free trade as well.
 

vampirekid.13

New member
May 8, 2009
821
0
0
step 1. stop humanitarian support for any country that pirates come from.
step 2. watch them slowly die out.
step 3. SUCCESS.


i was so happy to hear we shot 3 of them on the last attack, i can only hope i get deployed in that region of the world with the ship im on now. seriously.
 

1337mokro

New member
Dec 24, 2008
1,503
0
0
The one thing Africa needs is to grow up.

Even now Africa is no better than the Eastern European dumps.
Tribes are killing each other, civil wars break out because some one belongs to the Hutu and not the Tutu. In other words people are getting killed for one letter difference.

This of course being an indirect link to Pirating with Somalia being driven to the point where it's people cannot sustain themselves.

In all this the West and China is possibly the biggest harm bringer. They fund nations governments when we all know that those governments are more crooked than our governments. What they should do is instead of giving money as support we should keep that money and instead invest it in blooming businesses there.

That way we don't have the luxury of charity organisation, we don't have to pay that much tax either seeing as we now have a few hundred million more and the government can instead of pocketing the aid and turning it in palatial estates only tax the money earned by those businesses which will make sure the level of corruption is lessened.

In short what we need to do is not kill all pirates because once you do that you create a void, which will be filled, but offer a better alternative, a job where a man can work and earn enough to support his family without the risk of losing his live.

Take a new approach to Third-world aid, rather than dumping cartloads of money on their doorsteps they should have to work for it because if they work for it they will secure the means to keep making that profit and not plunge into poverty the second we turn down the money tap.
 

vampirekid.13

New member
May 8, 2009
821
0
0
1337mokro said:
The one thing Africa needs is to grow up.

Even now Africa is no better than the Eastern European dumps.
Tribes are killing each other, civil wars break out because some one belongs to the Hutu and not the Tutu. In other words people are getting killed for one letter difference.

This of course being an indirect link to Pirating with Somalia being driven to the point where it's people cannot sustain themselves.

In all this the West and China is possibly the biggest harm bringer. They fund nations governments when we all know that those governments are more crooked than our governments. What they should do is instead of giving money as support we should keep that money and instead invest it in blooming businesses there.

That way we don't have the luxury of charity organisation, we don't have to pay that much tax either seeing as we now have a few hundred million more and the government can instead of pocketing the aid and turning it in palatial estates only tax the money earned by those businesses which will make sure the level of corruption is lessened.

In short what we need to do is not kill all pirates because once you do that you create a void, which will be filled, but offer a better alternative, a job where a man can work and earn enough to support his family without the risk of losing his live.

Take a new approach to Third-world aid, rather than dumping cartloads of money on their doorsteps they should have to work for it because if they work for it they will secure the means to keep making that profit and not plunge into poverty the second we turn down the money tap.

YOU TAKE THAT BACK RIGHT NOW. EASTERN EUROPE IS FREAKING AWESOME. TAKE IT BACK.







or ill make you >.<