A Review of Penny Arcade, an ultimately futile exercise in review writing.

Recommended Videos

PedroSteckecilo

Mexican Fugitive
Feb 7, 2008
6,732
0
0
Writing a ?review? of Penny Arcade is pointless, as no opinion, either good or bad, could do a damn thing to dent their traffic. As well summing up exactly what Penny Arcade consists of is a similar exercise in frivolity. Hence this is basically an opinion piece, my thoughts on how Penny Arcade moved beyond being a simple web-comic about gaming to an international sensation, which still keeps videogames firmly in its heart but has grown into an exercise in creative madness.

I will start with, in my opinion, the most recent affirmation of what Penny Arcade has become. ?Paint the Line? a long, dreaded continuity storyline revolving around an imagined action movie from the 80?s based entirely around Ping Pong, or table tennis, or whatever. The results are amusing, hilarious and truly telling of how far Penny Arcade has come as a web-comic. A ping pong showdown atop a nuclear submarine which ends in victory by default due to Orca intervention, the flames of passion atop a rocket, and a final showdown in a space station, all with tongue planted firmly in cheek and evoking whole heartedly the spirit of all those anti-soviet action movies produced in the 80?s. The artwork is dynamic, colorful and the writing clever though heavy on the exposition. Furthermore amusing phrases like ?Lenin?s Daughters? or ?The Experimental ?Peoples Grip?? hammer home the entertainment for me.

My second choice for telling Penny Arcade features that set it above the pack is the under appreciated Twisp & Catsby stories (I call them underappreciated because apparently people would rather have more Div than these two? idiots). A small devil and a giant cat whom speak in non sequiturs and wander around their truly strange world having mad adventure after mad adventure, it?s a far more amusing diversion than CAD?s attempt at bizarro humor, the random and non-that-funny Chef Brian. Rarely, in any form of media, is blatant surrealism so well expressed and the Twisp and Catsby stories are well drawn, creative, confusing, surreal and endlessly entertaining all at the same time, and I wait earnestly every year for when they will put out another one of these gems.

The list does go on however, Card Board Tube Samurai, The Last Christmas, The Saga of the Deep Crow are excellent examples of the creative talent behind this comic, something that frequently pushes the comic beyond its somewhat formulaic, and occasionally bland blend of profanity and violence laced gaming and pop-culture humor. This in addition to the constantly improving artwork and writing is the reason I keep checking back every Monday, Wednesday and Friday and continually hit refresh until a new comic has been posted.
 

McChiken

New member
Jul 2, 2008
17
0
0
Wow when I read the tittle I thought I was going to have to put on the fanboy battle boots and defend Tycho and Gabe. But it looks like you like it a lot!
 

Meatshield27

New member
Jun 30, 2008
5
0
0
If you don't like something, keep it to yourself. Don't voice your worthless opinion then call it a review.
 

Meatshield27

New member
Jun 30, 2008
5
0
0
Bling Cat said:
Meatshield27 said:
You're not Yahtzee.
how is that in ANY WAY relevant? On topic, I liked your review, and I agree, I liked the paint the line series.
Well, he's reviewing what he already did, webcomics, try to be more original next time.

Edit: my bad, you're not the OP.
 

Somethingironic

New member
Jul 5, 2008
102
0
0
McChiken said:
Wow when I read the tittle I thought I was going to have to put on the fanboy battle boots and defend Tycho and Gabe. But it looks like you like it a lot!
Fanboy battle boots you say?

I had already primed my MECHA FANBOY BATTLEGEAR....


But still, good re...po....good runthrough of Penny Arcade? I can't really say review...
 

qbert4ever

New member
Dec 14, 2007
798
0
0
Meatshield27 said:
You're not Yahtzee.
Really now? What tipped you off? The lack of moving pictures and audio, or the fact that the name tag says "PadroSteckecilo"?

Back on topic, it was decent, but kinda short. A review of a webcomic is an odd pick in itself, but nothing in your review would have made me want to check it out if I wasn't already a fan. Add a bit more depth, and keep praticing, and who knows what may happen.
 

PedroSteckecilo

Mexican Fugitive
Feb 7, 2008
6,732
0
0
Frankly, I'm reviewing whatever the hell I can, purely on the basis that I want to become a better reviewer. I enjoyed writing this one, but yes, I should have fleshed it out more.

Though I suppose Yahtzee did spur this review, I figured that since the subject of webcomics is extremely apparent at the moment, why the hell not write a pointless review of Penny Arcade.
 

qbert4ever

New member
Dec 14, 2007
798
0
0
Meatshield27 said:
If you don't like something, keep it to yourself. Don't voice your worthless opinion then call it a review.
So doesn't that make you a bit of a hypocrite by putting up your own "worthless oppinion"?
 

Doggabone

New member
May 11, 2007
42
0
0
the monopoly guy said:
Meatshield27 said:
If you don't like something, keep it to yourself. Don't voice your worthless opinion then call it a review.
...he liked it...what the hell are you reading?
Y'know, I assumed he/she was roleplaying the fanboy boots.
 

Evilbunny

New member
Feb 23, 2008
2,099
0
0
Doggabone said:
the monopoly guy said:
Meatshield27 said:
If you don't like something, keep it to yourself. Don't voice your worthless opinion then call it a review.
...he liked it...what the hell are you reading?
Y'know, I assumed he/she was roleplaying the fanboy boots.
I assumed he didn't actually read the review.