pantsoffdanceoff said:
Adaptations don't work becuase lets face it, movies and games are two completely different forms of art. It would be like trying to make the Mona Lisa a movie, it just doesn't translate.
Oh?
IMBD #1: adapted from short story
IMDB #2,3: adapted from novel
IMDB #6: adapted from comic
IMDB #7: adapted from novel
IMDB #8: adapted from novel
Many successful games, including innovative ones and/or ones considered to be classics, are adaptations of works in other media. X-Wing, Dark Forces, GoldenEye 64, The Witcher, and so on. Discussed many times in previous threads.
Game -> movie remains shit not because it's impossible to make good movies out of games, but because they seem to be picking games that are reasonably popular and easy to make a crappy movie out of, *not* ones that would make the best movies. It has gotten so bad, I would no longer be surprised if someone greenlighted a movie based on "The Sims", despite there being no conceivable point to such a thing other than separating idiots and their money.
No game movie was ever made in the spirit Watchmen, Sin City or some of the better Batman movies were.