Alright, I'm distinguishing between anime I really liked and anime that quote blew me away unquote, because those
are different things. Now, let's begin:
Death Note
The timeless tale of a genius college student eating potato chips, Death Note showcases a roller coaster ride of a mind game plot, but just as importantly, it's Studio Madhouse doing what they do best. No, not boob physics, the
other thing they do best. Yeah, melodrama. In a show about people sitting around talking, the camera zips around like crazy and the Ominous Latin Choir does its thing. In short, it is...JUSTICE!
Code Geass: Lelouch of the Rebellion
If Death Note and Gundam had a child, and that child was on crack, it would be Code Geass. Mech combat! Intricate schemes! Anti-hero protagonist! High school hijinks! CLAMP! Holy hell, Code Geass has
everything, for good and for bad.
Fate/Zero
When gigguk reviewed this show, he paused for a moment, searching for the right word, and described it as "mature". And that's a good way to describe it. Other ways to describe it might be "gorgeous beyond belief" and "OMG RIDER SO AWSUM" (I'm more partial to Gilgamesh myself, but
everyone likes Rider). Here, you know what? Just listen to this:
And oh, if you were wondering, Fate/stay night really is as bad as you've heard. The Fate/stay night anime cannot even hold a candle to how incredibly awful the first two routes of the visual novel are. Heaven's Feel, the third route, is apparently...well, I was going to say "the Holy Grail of the Fate series", but that seems inappropriate given the context, so I guess I'll say it's the Valve of the Fate series or something, but I have not read it yet, so I will reserve judgment for the moment.
Puella Magi Madoka Magica
If you've already seen Madoka, you know what I mean. If you haven't, please stop what you are doing and go watch it right now. I'm not going to say anything about it. Don't go read reviews, or see what people have to say about it. Don't read any of the other posts
in this thread about it. Just watch it. Please.
"Don't forget. Always, somewhere, someone is fighting for you. As long as you remember her, you are not alone."
Bleach
I know, I know, but this isn't a thread about good anime, this a thread about anime that
blew you away. Now sure, I was young and not as wise as I am now, but somewhere around episode 40 I realized, "hey wait a minute...this show is AWESOME!" Because it kind of is. Kind of.
Kokoro Connect
This show blew me away in a way a bit different from the others. It's a great show, though not on the level of everything else (except Bleach, of course), but it blew me away in two respects. One, it was the show that made me realize I could like things other than action shows (everything else on this list is an action show, after all). Two, and this is really a personal thing, but at the time I was freshly disappointed by SAO, but at the same time I was forced to admit it was the best series of the Summer 2012 season. Then I was recommended Kokoro Connect, and after that I was forced to admit
nothing. Take that, SAO, take that! Your grand sword-fighting adventure doesn't hold a candle to Kokoroco's heart-wrenching, body-swapping comedic romance melodrama!
Ikasury said:
every time someone mentions SAO i just b*tchslap them and point them towards DOT//:hack. cause honestly, the whole deal with video game world sucking you in? hmm? that sounds awfully familiar -.- plus the characters are a lot better, both in the dynamic of who they are IN 'The World' and who they are 'outside' it... SAO just felt shallow all around... plus no Helba *glomps* you're my favorite hacker, no matter what the Major says~
Bla bla bla. Look, there's only one reason to not like SAO: because it's bad. I hate the "X is similar to Y, and Y is good, therefore X sucks" argument to begin with, and in this case it's doubly infuriating because SAO very obviously is not derivative of .hack. SAO sucks for its own, very personal reasons. On the other hand, unlike .hack//SIGN at least, SAO is always...well, exciting might be too strong a word, but at least always in motion. Whereas when I watched .hack//SIGN I was more bored than I'd been since I watched Elfen Lied. Yes, I was bored watching Elfen Lied.