Are Emulators legal or ilegal?

Dreiko_v1legacy

New member
Aug 28, 2008
4,696
0
0
You need to dump your own bios off of your console but if you do own the console, the fact that you don't own the devices for dumping the BIOS don't make it suddenly stealing, despite being technically illegal. It's just a mutual loophole that both companies and emulating folk use to not fight with each-other, the people pretending to all having dumped their own BIOS since they own the consoles and the companies not minding since, well, most consoles that are emulated are at least last generation or before than, meaning they've sold enough and won't sell any more and the only thing companies would accomplish going after emulators would be to seem like assholes.

As for roms, that's another thing, even if you own the game, you're still not allowed to make copies of it on your computer, since it's copyrighted, though it is definitely moral to choose to play a game you own on your PC rather than on an old inconvenient console, so take that as you will.


For me in theory, the only real use of emulators would be regarding portable systems since a lot of good games are practically ruined by the tiny screens on which they are on. Playing them on a big PC screen does them justice.
 

Epona

Elite Member
Jun 24, 2011
4,221
0
41
Country
United States
Technically speaking you can backup your media and I personally don't see the difference in backing it up yourself or downloading a copy and I don't think there is a legal distinction either.

On the other hand, you can't backup copy protected media which makes the right to backup your media void since almost everything you would want to backup has copy protection.

As for the BIOS, if you own the console I don't see why the same rules wouldn't apply. You own a PS2 then you have the right to use the BIOS just like you can use that Final Fantasy X disc. Further, the ported games your download off of the Wii Virtual Console or PSN are running emulators. If Nintendo or Sony can emulate games....

I think the law is inconsistent and no one really knows what is or is not legal where emulators, BIOS and ROMS are concerned so everyone just guesses or makes it up as they go along. People are going to either use emulators or not but if they do they won't admit to it on this site and that limits the discussion.
 

DigitalSushi

a gallardo? fine, I'll take it.
Dec 24, 2008
5,718
0
0
Emulators are legal, downloading ROMS and using them is not if you don't have the original game copy, because you haven't purchased the license to play it.

ANALOGY TIME CHILDREN!
Your allowed to own a Ferrari, a car capable of Mach 2, but your not allowed to drive at 190mph on public roads because while the car can do it you are breaking laws such as speeding and dangerous driving.

Emulators and by extension Ferrari's don't break the law, how you use them however can be infringing on the law.

Its not illegal to have rolling up paper for tobacco, but using said roll up to roll Mary Jane then thats the bit that the Police and Lawyers have issues with.

You allowed to have an LG HDTV, but once you try to make a giant mechanical spider out of it your friends will shun you (stuck in the past I say!), you get the idea I'm sure.

aprilmarie said:
Tanakh said:
aprilmarie said:
Which is why that is exactly what I did.
Nice! I must admit being less scrupulous back in the day.

Despite what you may get out of my profile photo or avi photo, I'm not just a pretty face with boobs. Or an insanely evil person either. I have brains and know how to use them. And am actually learning how to build my own computer.
Your picture actually kinda scares me, its that angle of attack as it were, same goes with LaCoil
T.T
 

Blow_Pop

Supreme Evil Overlord
Jan 21, 2009
4,863
0
0
ColdStorage said:
aprilmarie said:
Tanakh said:
aprilmarie said:
Which is why that is exactly what I did.
Nice! I must admit being less scrupulous back in the day.

Despite what you may get out of my profile photo or avi photo, I'm not just a pretty face with boobs. Or an insanely evil person either. I have brains and know how to use them. And am actually learning how to build my own computer.
Your picture actually kinda scares me, its that angle of attack as it were, same goes with LaCoil
T.T
That's the point of the photo. Hence why it was taken that way. Just wait til I get a photo in my work costume for the next month and a half *grins evilly*