Battlefield 3 Beta - Your Thoughts?

[go-10]

I've enjoyed the hell out of it but I'll be honest I'm using a sniper and that thing is overpowered as hell!
the commando class is useless unless laying down
medics are immortal, combine them with a shotgun and close quarters and you'll rack up kills like crazy
engineers are rpg maniacs and the destruction they cause is abysmal

overall I've had a couple of problems (falling through the ground, objects disappearing, gun doesn't load even though I can still shoot, and not being able to assign the controller to whatever button I want REALLY sucks) other than that the only thing I hope they change is squad formations, sniper overpower, and knife attacks should only be a knife attack not a separate weapon that's equipped if you stealth kill someone. 6 out of 10 times I would die because the game would equip me with a knife and not let me shoot at a close by enemy after a stealth kill

 

[JochemDude]

What I do know I'm gonna hate is the lack of squadbuilding, you can't select which squad to be in and if you join a friend the game could just aswell put you in the other team. Bad part is that they already said this was not a glitch and WILL stay this way.

What?! Are you sure?
Can you show me the quote when they said this?
That'll piss me off if you can't choose your squad/squadmates.

https://twitter.com/#!/zh1nt0/status/120072134226751488
You can do it through battlelog, but if other players have already connected to the server they'll be automaticly assigned to squads, meaning that you can't create additional squads. The jist of it is that unless you and your people are prepared to wait for a server to fill up, it's all coming down to luck.

 

[AssassinFisH]

Not overly impressed with the console beta. I must admit, the weapons feel really tight and punchy which I really like, but everything else seems more Bad company than battlefield.

The graphics are certainly nothing special and the annoying spawn times drive me mad! I admit, im used to cod spawns...ie die and respawn straight away. I think that works better than getting repeatedly spawn sniped, then having to watch the guy for 10 seconds.

My biggest gripe however, is the damn right stick crouch/prone. Why can't you change it? I am very heavy handed, and whenever I am trying to aim at an enemy during a firefight, I repeatedly crouch or prone unwillingly. I wouldn't complain if there was an option to switch it to B! As it stands, it makes the whole experience frustrating rather than fun.

 

[josemlopes]

Like, you can still one-Knife kill a guy, but when you do, the game plays through a short animation, during which you can still be shot.
So it's not just a winning strategy, unless you can find people alone.
And if you can, the team who gets knifed deserves what they get.

Is it also true that you have to select the knife as any other weapon? Just like in the olden days? Because I got that idea from another gameplay video, this one. [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SDcbaR1THPQ&feature=related] If it's true, then huzzah!

If it's like the alpha, you can press a button to knife, or take out your knife.

So what's the advantage of taking your knife out? A shorter kill animation?

The diference is that if you have a gun and whant to knife someone it still takes some time for the character to actually knife the enemy (he will put his gun down, equip the knife and then do the stab but after all that time the enemy may not be in range so you can miss the stab, if you already had the knife equiped you will make the stab instantly so he doesnt get away)

 

[dillirgaf]

i would be willing to wait a while longer so they can get it right. the PS3 version has a horrible bug of falling through the level

 

[DVS Storm]

The demo is awesome imo, even though it is full of bugs, but that's natural so I cannot complain. Most of the things that are wrong in the beta are bugs. Like the fact that sometimes a headshot from a bolt-action sniper rifle doesn't kill. I can live with those, since they're going to be patched out.

I play the beta on my Xbox since my PC cannot run it(which is really sad) and the thing that bothers me is the lack of teamplay. People just run around killing each other and don't give a shit about disarming the objective. I also can't remember the last time someone threw me an ammokit or a medickit. Or revived me(though reviving is really hard due to the bugs but still). I know it's just a beta but I just hope that in the game itself people will try to do something else than running around by themselves(this is just my observation from the beta so far).

 

[Thomiroth]

I played it for about 30 minutes, and my initial impression was to go right back to Bad Company 2, because this feels like a step backwards.

I wish I didn't agree with this, but it mirrors my thoughts exactly. It feels like CoD (which means I might as well buy MWF3 instead) and just doesn't have that clunky 'I'm actually carrying around a 50 pound backpack, plus armaments' feel I found quite endearing.

There's not much I can see that is directly wrong with the game, though, it's just a pretty standard FPS. That's another problem though. It's average.

On the whole, I've decided not to waste my money, and to forget about getting excited about new games anymore until they're actually out.

 

[ZehMadScientist]

I like the game, it is just that I find being a defender laughably easy, and on the flip side being an attacker can be quite infuriating.

 

[MajWound]

Playing with a squad making tactical decisions is so much more rewarding than sprinting around lone wolf style going for that awesome k/d ratio and I find myself playing in a very realistic manner (so far as fps goes). The thing that i think gets a lot of players, is that sprinting towards the objective is a surefire way to get killed. You have to work your way there, with the squad, you mightn't be the first player there, but you feel like you've made a difference as part of a team by laying down covering fire and healing your team mates.

I have problems playing "teamwork" games with the type of people usually found in online games. There can be four outcomes to this:

You do it right and your team does it right: Everybody wins.

You do it wrong and your team does it right: You might win, but everyone hates you.

You do it right and your team does it wrong: You probably lose, and you hate everyone.

You do it wrong and your team does it wrong: You simply lose, and everyone hates everyone.

Everyone here knows that random teammates can never be consistently relied upon. And then there are griefers, lobbing smoke grenades at your snipers and throwing ammo refills in the lake. They are the reason I prefer to work by myself, Sam Fisher-style, to complete the objective while the rest of my team hangs back and jerks each other off.

 

[Rhymenoceros]

I've had it on xbox for a few days now and I'm loving it!
I havent encountered any bugs apart from one persons character model going a little bit crazy...

And as a long term CoD player I find that if I'm playing with a team of friends I prefer to CoD but for lone wolf gameplay CoD is more fun IMHO. Which suits each games reputation I think

Edit: One balancing issue I've encountered is that it seems much easier to defend than attack. On Metro at least

 

[Rhymenoceros]

What?! Are you sure?
Can you show me the quote when they said this?
That'll piss me off if you can't choose your squad/squadmates.

Ya that doesnt seem right. When I was starting it up it asked me if I wanted to be put in a squad automatically or join one on my own. You might not be able to choose what team you are on but definitly the squad.

I don't think you can. Because me and 2 friends of mine played together for a few hours yesterday and one of us was always put in a squad with strangers and no matter how hard/long we tried we couldn't link up. Even though we joined the game together

 

[Mr.Luigi]

I really loved it! I was always more of a CoD guy, but I loved how it makes you move slower and more tactically in the map. Advancing with the team and going for objectives is very rewarding. Reminded me of the crouch only servers in CoD. Can't wait to play with the vehicles, I remember that was my favorite part back when I played BF1.

 

[xOriigins]

It's pretty good besides the glitches and I'm having fun with it. Sucks that they chose that map to showcase it though.

 

[Kopikatsu]

It's pretty good besides the glitches and I'm having fun with it. Sucks that they chose that map to showcase it though.

People keep saying that they chose Operation Metro to 'showcase' BF3, but...

This is a beta. They probably chose Operation Metro because it was the buggiest map they had...

 

[Burn2Feel]

Just so you know, the thing with the knife, the ammo box, and the med kit being held like a regular weapon is actually a feature, not a bug. You can ready grenades like that, too. It allows you to use them more quickly, and is also a feature going all the way back to 1942, which didn't allow for one button grenades, knifing, or anything else.

Oh, fair enough. My friend said that the ammo and med box were bugs since he's played more of the games than me, so I assumed they were too.

 

[TacticalAssassin1]

They just unlocked the Caspian Border map.
I'm happy!

 

[Still Life]

They just unlocked the Caspian Border map.
I'm happy!

Lags like an old, arthritic man in an 200m sprint on the Aus/NZ servers. Looks great, though.

 

[TacticalAssassin1]

They just unlocked the Caspian Border map.
I'm happy!

Lags like an old, arthritic man in an 200m sprint on the Aus/NZ servers. Looks great, though.

Yep, I'm experiencing the same thing. Oh well... Maybe tomorrow.

 

[Still Life]

They just unlocked the Caspian Border map.
I'm happy!

Lags like an old, arthritic man in an 200m sprint on the Aus/NZ servers. Looks great, though.

Yep, I'm experiencing the same thing. Oh well... Maybe tomorrow.

Tried again. Not nearly as much lag (quite smooth now), but I'm getting server disconnects the same way I did earlier in the beta with Metro.

I'm positive Dice will have a perfectly playable and largely polished game on release, but boy is it annoying

 

[Malfy]

The beta version I played had a clipping bug, and me getting sniped a lot. You die a bit too easily, which I guess is supposed to make you sneak around and use strategy a lot more so you'll have someone off-guard in your sights, but it's more of an annoyance than anything. No point in headshots when two shots kill everyone.

Yes, it's just a beta release, but there's nothing I've seen that makes me want to shell another $60 for this FPS or any other in the near future.