Ellie and Elizabeth are both fantastic characters, though as Bloatedguppy points out, it's a shame they aren't given the focus they truly deserve.
The Boss is another great one mentioned, though she's skirting the decade line.
Zoey from Dreamfall: The Longest Journey is a good character. The game isn't the best piece of fiction I've ever played, but the characters are memorable and Zoey stands out from the typical female representation in games, especially back in 2006. April Ryan is equally good, though in Dreamfall she's not as substantial as a character as she was in the original Longest Journey, which is too old to nominate.
Someone mentioned Flemeth. I wholeheartedly agree. Flemeth is enigmatic, powerful and possibly the most intriguing character in Dragon Age lore. At times she can feel a little cliche if you are looking at narratives from all mediums, but as far as games go she's surprisingly refreshing. I also think Morrigan is worth mentioning, but that might be because I've got a thing for Claudia black.
Speaking of Claudia Black, I think Chloe from Uncharted 2 and 3 (maybe? I can't remember her role in 3 very well) is worth a mention. A vast improvement over Elena from the first Uncharted, though even she becomes a sold character as the series progresses.
There are certain things you can extrapolate about an Avatars intended personality by the actions you are forced to take over the course of a game. But to claim that makes them the "Best" characters in gaming is setting the bar awfully low or painting a really ugly picture of the state of gaming (or gamers themselves).
Honestly, what's more perplexing to me is that People choose Chell over Glados. She's an excellent character. Glados has far more of a presence then chell and for most of the game she's just a disembodied voice.
The Boss is another great one mentioned, though she's skirting the decade line.
Zoey from Dreamfall: The Longest Journey is a good character. The game isn't the best piece of fiction I've ever played, but the characters are memorable and Zoey stands out from the typical female representation in games, especially back in 2006. April Ryan is equally good, though in Dreamfall she's not as substantial as a character as she was in the original Longest Journey, which is too old to nominate.
Someone mentioned Flemeth. I wholeheartedly agree. Flemeth is enigmatic, powerful and possibly the most intriguing character in Dragon Age lore. At times she can feel a little cliche if you are looking at narratives from all mediums, but as far as games go she's surprisingly refreshing. I also think Morrigan is worth mentioning, but that might be because I've got a thing for Claudia black.
Speaking of Claudia Black, I think Chloe from Uncharted 2 and 3 (maybe? I can't remember her role in 3 very well) is worth a mention. A vast improvement over Elena from the first Uncharted, though even she becomes a sold character as the series progresses.
So would you say the "Commander" in a command and conquer game is a character? What about The Keeper in Dungeon Keeper (not the Horned Reaper mind you)? Or the nondescript entity that controls the lives of the Sims? If yes, would you call them the "Best" characters in gaming?Story said:Just out of couristy though does Chell not have personality because she's viewed through a first person perspective? Aren't the actions taken by the player part of her personality?Silvanus said:Silent protagonists can have a lot of personality; an example would be Amaterasu, who is characterised through quite a lot of expressive body language (aided by the art style) and her interactions with other characters. Chell doesn't get that.
I would put forward Ellie (The Last of Us), Lulu or Yuna (Final Fantasy X) and GLaDOS (Portal) as my picks.
I don't want to derail the thread even farther, I think I'll just make a new topic on the subject when I have the chance.
There are certain things you can extrapolate about an Avatars intended personality by the actions you are forced to take over the course of a game. But to claim that makes them the "Best" characters in gaming is setting the bar awfully low or painting a really ugly picture of the state of gaming (or gamers themselves).
Honestly, what's more perplexing to me is that People choose Chell over Glados. She's an excellent character. Glados has far more of a presence then chell and for most of the game she's just a disembodied voice.