Susan Arendt said:
I believe the quote is referring to any of the numerous "Game of the Year" awards BioShock received.
How many could...oh, wow. [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Game_of_the_Year]
With so many GOTY titles available out there, you would think the whole thing would lose all meaning. Sure, most games given GOTY status are undoubtedly worth giving a look for consumers, but its not like a developer's game can truly be ranked "number one" when there are so many other magazines passing out the same award too.
Then again, I'm no video game developer. Maybe each time you win it, it still gives you that warm fuzzy feeling...