You know what, pretty much any song by Bob Dylan or Leonard Cohen I'm bound to like a cover version better. I just think they're vocals are mediocre and the music in the covers often has a lot more to offer. Come at me bro!
It's funny how every cover of this song has gotten progressively better, Rod Steawart's version trumping the orginal by Chris Farlowe and The Stereophonics rendition standing head and shoulder's above them both, the pacing and production feels a lot better and Kelly Jones really puts a lot more emotion and vigour into the vocals.
I just found the original of this to be increadibly tepid, while this version offers a heavier, more crushing instrumentation along with Hetfield's more sinister vocals does a much better job at conveying the tone the original was trying to impart. So well done Metallica (but I still think your cover of Whiskey in the Jar is just bland >.>).
Again I think Thin Lizzy just bring a lot more verve to this performance, particularly on that guitar solo which just feels lifeless on the original and frankly I just much prefer Phil Lynott's vocals to Bob Seger.
The original has too much of a psychedelic vibe for my liking, the keyboards feel pretty jarring and the vocals just sound completely off kilter. Black Sabbath just made something that feels a lot more bluesy; Tony Iommi's guitar work on this is simply masterful, he's on fire with those solo's and Geezer's sexy bass really adds a lot to the sound as it builds up, Ozzy's vocals actually feel more woeful and has a better sense of pitch and it really just seems more creative, they took this song and really ran with it and made it their own.
This one's just for funsies.
Honestly, this one can make me smile every time I play it unlike the original. XD