Andy Chalk said:
Not buying this game is going to drive me crazy. I've passed on games I've been iffy about before, but never one I wanted this badly. But always online = no money from me.
That said, I have every confidence that Blizzard will deliver. Blizzard didn't get to where it is today by being lucky.
The higher they are, the harder they fall. Nothing lasts forever and Blizzard pulling the online-only move just for extra cash in the auction house is a hard turn into dark alley, frankly.
It doesn't matter if it isn't for DRM purposes. Blizzard has had its bad days before with its servers, and I have to wonder how many people are going to get screwed off some once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for some easy money when they lose a sale because of a server hiccup.
I don't even like the auction house being a factor in the always-on affair because it creates an edge for cashiered players. It doesn't matter that the items they can buy can also be found in the game. It is going to create an atmosphere of intimidation where, over time, cashiered players won't want to have anything to do with those who can't buy from the auction house because they can't get the uber items.
Blizzard isn't doing this for all Diablo fans. They see a very large demographic over in Asia willing to plunk down extra change for their games addiction, and those of us in the Western Hemisphere and Europe can just deal with it. It feels kind of like the prohibition, only the mafia puts most of their speak-easy's in Irish country because they know that's where the most booze will be sold. Who cares about the other people who would prefer not to stand out like a sore-thumb to get a shot of whiskey?
This kind of action soils the entire game for me to the point I don't even want to deal with Blizzard again. Besides, who is to say they don't pull this same crap with the next Starcraft II? How hard would it be to make the special units you earn in the single-player campaign available in the auction house to buy for use in multiplayer? This is like TF2 and its system taken to the dark side. Of a very filthy alley.
No, you will find me playing Torchlight and Torchlight 2, thank you very much. And for less money and more high hopes.