Blizzard Sued Over Battle.net Authenticators

Andy Chalk

One Flag, One Fleet, One Cat
Nov 12, 2002
45,698
1
0
Blizzard Sued Over Battle.net Authenticators


Blizzard says it will "vigorously defend itself" against claims that it does not adequately safeguard its customers' data unless they pay extra for a Battle.net authenticator.

World of Warcraft studio Blizzard Entertainment was hit with a class action lawsuit late last week over allegations of "deceptive upselling" relating to its Battle.net authenticators. The suit claims that Blizzard and its parent company Activision Blizzard fail to inform consumers that they "must" purchase additional products - the authenticators - in order to ensure that their data is adequately secured on Blizzard's servers.

"Blizzard requires all of its customers to establish accounts with its online gaming service, Battle.net, but it fails to disclose to consumers, prior to purchase, that they'll need additional products called authenticators to keep information stored in these accounts safe," attorney Hank Bates of law firm Carney Williams Bates Pulliam & Bowman PLLC said in a statement. "Even though the company frequently receives complaints about accounts being hacked, it simply tells the customer to attach an authenticator to their account. Blizzard doesn't inform people about this requirement when they purchase the game, and that amounts to a deceptive trade practice."

The suit also accuses Blizzard of "negligence" for failing to maintain adequate levels of security for its customer base, which "compromised millions of customers' email addresses, passwords, answers to personal security questions, and other items of sensitive information."

Blizzard, unsurprisingly, dismissed the allegations outright. "The suit's claim that we didn't properly notify players regarding the August 2012 security breach is not true. Not only did Blizzard act quickly to provide information to the public about the situation, we explained the actions we were taking and let players know how the incident affected them, including the fact that no names, credit card numbers, or other sensitive financial information was disclosed," the studio said.

The claim that an authenticator is required to maintain security is also "completely untrue and apparently based on a misunderstanding of the authenticator's purpose," it continued, clarifying that "the Battle.net Authenticator is an optional tool that players can use to further protect their Battle.net accounts in the event that their login credentials are compromised outside of Blizzard's network infrastructure."

"Many players have voiced strong approval for our security-related efforts," it said. "Blizzard deeply appreciates the outpouring of support it has received from its players related to the frivolous claims in this particular suit."

The lawsuit claims that Blizzard has earned $26 million from authenticator sales alone. The lead plaintiff in the case, Benjamin Bell, is seeking unspecified damages as well as an injunction preventing Blizzard from charging additional post-purchase costs to its customers and requiring them to sign up to its Battle.net service.

Sources: GamesIndustry [http://www.joystiq.com/2012/11/10/blizzard-faces-class-action-suit-over-account-authenticators/]


Permalink
 

NLS

Norwegian Llama Stylist
Jan 7, 2010
1,594
0
0
It's optional. If you can't keep your own account safe, then you deserve it.
 

Aeshi

New member
Dec 22, 2009
2,640
0
0
SecretNegative said:
Honestly, I feel the authenticators should be free. If your highest point of security costs extra of a game that you not only have to buy, but pay a subscription for, then I feel you've gotten a bit greedy. It's not like it's a ton of extra content to produce anyway, and Blizz won't run out of money in a long time.
If you have a mobile phone it is free, to my knowledge you only have to pay if you want the authenticator stick (basically a small USB stick with the authenticator on it) and I think even then you pay for the hardware more than the program on it.
 

Roxas1359

Burn, Burn it All!
Aug 8, 2009
33,758
1
0
I'm more sick of the fact that they keep sending me emails about my account when I don't even have one! I've gotten like 30 emails about how my "account has not paid the dues necessary" over the past 3 months and it's annoying because I don't even have an account. I email the main people for their tech and account stuff telling them to deactivate my so called account but it would seem they still haven't done that.
Went back to dig up the old emails, turns out it wasn't for paying or anything but it was about cheating. Still applies though since I don't even have an account.
 

Baldr

The Noble
Jan 6, 2010
1,739
0
0
Battle.net is free. Mobile and landline phone authenticators are free. However, here the kicker: World of Warcraft features are not fully functional without an authenticator. The list of these things is tiny and only require for extra security stuff like guild vaults. The suit is wrong though.
 

BeerTent

Resident Furry Pimp
May 8, 2011
1,167
0
0
Neronium said:
I'm more sick of the fact that they keep sending me emails about my account when I don't even have one! I've gotten like 30 emails about how my "account has not paid the dues necessary" over the past 3 months and it's annoying because I don't even have an account. I email the main people for their tech and account stuff telling them to deactivate my so called account but it would seem they still haven't done that.
Check the sender in the email's source. They're likely phishing emails.
 

Seventh Actuality

New member
Apr 23, 2010
551
0
0
Neronium said:
I'm more sick of the fact that they keep sending me emails about my account when I don't even have one! I've gotten like 30 emails about how my "account has not paid the dues necessary" over the past 3 months and it's annoying because I don't even have an account. I email the main people for their tech and account stuff telling them to deactivate my so called account but it would seem they still haven't done that.
Yeah, I don't think that's Blizzard.
 

Roxas1359

Burn, Burn it All!
Aug 8, 2009
33,758
1
0
BeerTent said:
Neronium said:
I'm more sick of the fact that they keep sending me emails about my account when I don't even have one! I've gotten like 30 emails about how my "account has not paid the dues necessary" over the past 3 months and it's annoying because I don't even have an account. I email the main people for their tech and account stuff telling them to deactivate my so called account but it would seem they still haven't done that.
Check the sender in the email's source. They're likely phishing emails.
That's the first thing I did and it sent me straight to them. I've blocked incoming emails from them now but it was so annoying that they couldn't even take the time to get back to me. It's like the Google Help Forums...my god those are terrible "help" forums.
 

Kenjitsuka

New member
Sep 10, 2009
3,051
0
0
Pre-Diablo 3 I was Pro Blizzard (since 1997), but now... Bah!
Don't care what the outcome will be.
Real Money AH will negate any effects.
 

Archemetis

Is Probably Awesome.
Aug 13, 2008
2,089
0
0
"Aaaaaah! I'm going to sue Blizzard because I can't be bothered to download a free authenticator app or actively keep my own account safe! Aaaaaaah!"

But really, from what I hear about the authenticators you're better off without and just taking your own active steps to safeguard your account.
 
Sep 14, 2009
9,073
0
0
NLS said:
It's optional. If you can't keep your own account safe, then you deserve it.
oh right, because on diablo III, the fact that I never played with anyone and never have been hacked/phished before, means that i'll be 100% safe?

yeah right, try again, my account was stolen within a week and a half of having the game, and it was the biggest pain in the ass trying to get it back with blizzards stupid support, because you have to call in and their lines are either always flooded or they don't have anyone to help you at the moment.
 

halfeclipse

New member
Nov 8, 2008
373
0
0
Neronium said:
I'm more sick of the fact that they keep sending me emails about my account when I don't even have one! I've gotten like 30 emails about how my "account has not paid the dues necessary" over the past 3 months and it's annoying because I don't even have an account. I email the main people for their tech and account stuff telling them to deactivate my so called account but it would seem they still haven't done that.

Yea that's what we call a phishing scam.

If an account doesn't pay for the subscription, then it just gets deactivated and maybe one of those "rejoin and drag someone new with you and get a free month of play!" a couple times a year. AFAIK Blizzard doesn't send any emails about "dues necessary" and certainly wouldn't do it constantly.
 

Roxas1359

Burn, Burn it All!
Aug 8, 2009
33,758
1
0
halfeclipse said:
Neronium said:
I'm more sick of the fact that they keep sending me emails about my account when I don't even have one! I've gotten like 30 emails about how my "account has not paid the dues necessary" over the past 3 months and it's annoying because I don't even have an account. I email the main people for their tech and account stuff telling them to deactivate my so called account but it would seem they still haven't done that.

Yea that's what we call a phishing scam.

If an account doesn't pay for the subscription, then it just gets deactivated and maybe one of those "rejoin and drag someone new with you and get a free month of play!" a couple times a year. AFAIK Blizzard doesn't send any emails about "dues necessary" and certainly wouldn't do it constantly.
Actually, I just went back to see what the email exactly was, turns out it wasn't about money, but it was saying that if I continue to "cheat" then I'd be banned.
 

mcattack92

New member
Feb 2, 2011
200
0
0
There is a free iOS and Android authenticator app made by Blizzard which you link it to your account so I don't see why they are suing over requiring to pay more to secure their data. It does the exact same thing the physical ones do.

http://itunes.apple.com/au/app/battle.net-mobile-authenticator/id306862897?mt=8
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.blizzard.bma&hl=en

The only ones who should be crying are the ones without an Android or iOS device.
 

Royas

New member
Apr 25, 2008
539
0
0
Neronium said:
halfeclipse said:
Neronium said:
I'm more sick of the fact that they keep sending me emails about my account when I don't even have one! I've gotten like 30 emails about how my "account has not paid the dues necessary" over the past 3 months and it's annoying because I don't even have an account. I email the main people for their tech and account stuff telling them to deactivate my so called account but it would seem they still haven't done that.

Yea that's what we call a phishing scam.

If an account doesn't pay for the subscription, then it just gets deactivated and maybe one of those "rejoin and drag someone new with you and get a free month of play!" a couple times a year. AFAIK Blizzard doesn't send any emails about "dues necessary" and certainly wouldn't do it constantly.
Actually, I just went back to see what the email exactly was, turns out it wasn't about money, but it was saying that if I continue to "cheat" then I'd be banned.
Definitely a scam. I've gotten many of those, for that exact reason, even though I haven't had an active account in a couple of years. They aren't from Blizzard, not a one. The link may go to a site that looks like a Blizzard site, but it isn't. Just an attempt to phish your login details.
 

halfeclipse

New member
Nov 8, 2008
373
0
0
Neronium said:
halfeclipse said:
Neronium said:
I'm more sick of the fact that they keep sending me emails about my account when I don't even have one! I've gotten like 30 emails about how my "account has not paid the dues necessary" over the past 3 months and it's annoying because I don't even have an account. I email the main people for their tech and account stuff telling them to deactivate my so called account but it would seem they still haven't done that.

Yea that's what we call a phishing scam.

If an account doesn't pay for the subscription, then it just gets deactivated and maybe one of those "rejoin and drag someone new with you and get a free month of play!" a couple times a year. AFAIK Blizzard doesn't send any emails about "dues necessary" and certainly wouldn't do it constantly.
Actually, I just went back to see what the email exactly was, turns out it wasn't about money, but it was saying that if I continue to "cheat" then I'd be banned.
From something like noreply/donotreply/etc@blizzard/battle/battlenet/etc.com/net/etc?

Remains a phishing scam. Used to get them myself semi-often before my block list finally nuked them all. The link it contains go to a dummy site prompting people to put in there account details, which are then used to steal any gold/items on the account and probably turn it into a spam or gold farming bot.
 

Roxas1359

Burn, Burn it All!
Aug 8, 2009
33,758
1
0
halfeclipse said:
Neronium said:
halfeclipse said:
Neronium said:
I'm more sick of the fact that they keep sending me emails about my account when I don't even have one! I've gotten like 30 emails about how my "account has not paid the dues necessary" over the past 3 months and it's annoying because I don't even have an account. I email the main people for their tech and account stuff telling them to deactivate my so called account but it would seem they still haven't done that.

Yea that's what we call a phishing scam.

If an account doesn't pay for the subscription, then it just gets deactivated and maybe one of those "rejoin and drag someone new with you and get a free month of play!" a couple times a year. AFAIK Blizzard doesn't send any emails about "dues necessary" and certainly wouldn't do it constantly.
Actually, I just went back to see what the email exactly was, turns out it wasn't about money, but it was saying that if I continue to "cheat" then I'd be banned.
From something like noreply/donotreply/etc@blizzard/battle/battlenet/etc.com/net/etc?

Remains a phishing scam. Used to get them myself semi-often before my block list finally nuked them all. The link it contains go to a dummy site prompting people to put in there account details, which are then used to steal any gold/items on the account and probably turn it into a spam or gold farming bot.
Ah, I see. Well I blocked them and it wouldn't matter since I don't even have an account for them to steal stuff from. XD
 

DrunkOnEstus

In the name of Harman...
May 11, 2012
1,712
0
0
I really don't see how it's the customer's fault if a hack occurs. If Blizzard insists that everyone who plays Diablo 3 has to make an account and be online/connected to their servers, doesn't it fall on them to ensure that their players' information is safe? If they are going to make it mandatory that I give them personal information, they damn well better be taking steps to secure the information on their end, because this kind of shit happens no matter what your password is if someone straight up hacks battle.net.

This suit is valid. Blizzard does not warn or advise anyone that their account isn't "truly" secure unless they have a smartphone or give them 6 bucks for a USB stick. They didn't make it at all clear before this that you can't use the RMAH unless you have a smartphone or give them 6 bucks. This suit is about Blizzard pushing the cost of one of their duties down to the consumer and profiting off of it. Please stop accepting this kind of crap and thinking it's totally cool. Nobody should demand personal information and refuse to keep it secure unless unspoken conditions are met.