I thought the same but decided against pointing it out. Also note that she/he is one more report away from a ban *shockandawe.jpg*Kurokami said:Your last sentence was meant to be ironic, right?voorhees123 said:Yes it can. I still thought it sucked, especially the ending. I thought the movie dealt with it better. If you love it then great, my comment means nothing at all, only to me. If you love it then great, i really dont care either way. Its my opinion. But your comment makes no sense above doesnt make sense.HumpinHop said:Not liking something doesn't degrade it to shit level. Something can be good, or even great and you're allowed to not like it.voorhees123 said:Because i read it and i didnt like it - and the squid ending was shit. How would you determine if something sucks?Wushu Panda said:Exactly how do you justify saying the comic sucks?voorhees123 said:Good for you. Have a cookie.ThatDaveDude1 said:I've seen the movie...I though it was offensively bad.voorhees123 said:Watch the movie. The comic sucks, especially the squid bit.ThatDaveDude1 said:I will never not recommend Watchmen.
I agree I didn't much care for the squid, but it did allow for a few more clues to be revealed as I recall in the comic, which summed up to a better ending imo. The book was also much better than the movie, I just pity anyone who watched it first then read the book, because I doubt you can still get that sense of uncertainty when reading it.
I know, my brother forced me to finish reading the comic before I was allowed to see the film, and by gum was that a good decision on his part. That uncertainty of not having a clue how it will end is what I loved so much about Watchmen, I can't remember any recent movie that had an ending I didn't see coming 15 minutes into the film.