The class I have a problem of the concept of (which is what the OP asked) is the "Thief".
I love stealthy gameplay, whether it's solo or in a group party. I think using the idea of sneakiness and avoiding attention is a good thing from a mechanical and a roleplaying perspective. What I don't like is the word, Thief.
A Thief is someone who steals things. Breaks into people's houses and robs them. Perhaps if they have some muscle, they might perform a mugging if necessary. What a Thief doesn't do is kill someone, that's a far greater crime that will draw far more attention without the material gain that a thief aims for. If I need to gather a party together to attack some giant demonspawn, what the hell is a Thief going to do for me? I need a demon to be defeated in combat and banished, so I need holy men, magic users, brave souls to put their lives on the line to protect the rest. When I need an heirloom stolen from a noble's bedroom, I'll call a thief.
Someone who uses stealth and misdirection to attack and kill their enemies is an "Assassin", not a "Thief". "Rogue" is just a runaway or someone who's untrustworthy, and can be applied to a Wizard who has abandoned their college to study forbidden arts.
Also, as a real life engineer (albeit not in the armed forces), calling a class with a blowtorch or wrench an "Engineer" is a pet peeve. No, you're a Mechanic. If carrying an anti-tank missile launcher defined an Engineer, I'd have a much higher job satisfaction.
I love stealthy gameplay, whether it's solo or in a group party. I think using the idea of sneakiness and avoiding attention is a good thing from a mechanical and a roleplaying perspective. What I don't like is the word, Thief.
A Thief is someone who steals things. Breaks into people's houses and robs them. Perhaps if they have some muscle, they might perform a mugging if necessary. What a Thief doesn't do is kill someone, that's a far greater crime that will draw far more attention without the material gain that a thief aims for. If I need to gather a party together to attack some giant demonspawn, what the hell is a Thief going to do for me? I need a demon to be defeated in combat and banished, so I need holy men, magic users, brave souls to put their lives on the line to protect the rest. When I need an heirloom stolen from a noble's bedroom, I'll call a thief.
Someone who uses stealth and misdirection to attack and kill their enemies is an "Assassin", not a "Thief". "Rogue" is just a runaway or someone who's untrustworthy, and can be applied to a Wizard who has abandoned their college to study forbidden arts.
Also, as a real life engineer (albeit not in the armed forces), calling a class with a blowtorch or wrench an "Engineer" is a pet peeve. No, you're a Mechanic. If carrying an anti-tank missile launcher defined an Engineer, I'd have a much higher job satisfaction.