Yes i haven't play Mass Effect of any related thing to that series..
(waits for the comments that insult me for not playing it)
Done with that? good. Why i don't play it? my reasons are my own for not liking it, i am the kind of person that finds more interesting watching the Red Letter Media videos about Star Wars rather than watching the movies, specially his comparison of George Lucas to Charles Foster Kane of the Citizen Kane movie.
However i find the ending controversy of Mass Effect 3 interesting on his own for his "impact" on the gaming world. So lets start at the beginning in a very short but necessary butchering of the events that lead me to this point.
After hearing some superficial news about "dumbing down ME3" and "Gears of Effect" and "Day 1 DLC = RAAAAAAAAGE" i didn't actually though highly of the ME fanbase even if they may be right about EA following the leader and tampering the development of a RPG series.
Then the game came out and the complains about the endings reached this very forum, i read most of them and agreed that they were badly executed and rushed, and since i am not a fan i therefore don't know about the lore but judge the game on his own merits in the same way that Mr. Plinket judges how the Star Wars prequels failed as films FIRST and the rest later....
.......But then i read the "Indoctrination Theory" about the endings and i understood perfectly the situation, in fact, it seems deceptively easy to understand to the point of being just weird that no fan catched up instantly to what is going on (unlike me). The last minutes of the game have attention to detail that only a fan of the whole series would understand, after all this is why this trope exist:
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TheLawOfConservationOfDetail
So here lies the problem. If Bioware wanted to have a large amount of fans to notice the ending details then why would they alienate them so much to the point of having no fans but newcomers, playing the game and declaring that its ending sucks because obviously they havent been previously exposed to the kind of information that a fan would have? The way i see that most people complain about the ending makes me believe that they were newcomers (like me even if don't play) who complaining CONSTANTLY without being absolutely clear except for very few exceptions. A demographic that wouldn't have appeared if they hadn't dumbed down ME3 and tried to appeal as many people as possible, things that made your fanbase leave the sinking ship before even reaching the endings.
The result is an ending that nobody gets what is the deal about it because its meaning isn't for the new people, its for the fanbase that is no longer there for being alienated of the idea of having their "perfect" game being played by the evils of *!GASP!* CASUALS!!!
But the biggest punch in the balls is that if it wasn't for the Internet age then this "real" ending wouldn't be even on the works. No wait, i take that back, even with the Internet, if the developers had taken more time to answer the endings issue then the fan reaction would most likely be "Oooooh, it was intended all along, yeah suuuuuuuuure buddy. Don't even try to win us over after what you did, you fucking traitor"
Just the mere idea of gamers being THIS irrational and hateful makes me believe that other games had suffered trough this and its one of the many reasons that the developers eventually lose their hope for making a unique game. After all, if a massive response to the endings come from people who dont know anything about the series at all then its more likely that Bioware just give up completely and let EA take decisions for them 100%, why try to leave a mark on the world when the people cant even remember something on a previous game or even something that was shown right in their faces?
Maybe we have so little confidence on games today that even the idea of subtlety in details just escapes our comprehension. We need to lay off the hate before it we become the unwitting pawns of the destruction of all future games.
Thank you for your time.
(Bonus points if you read all this with the Dark Age ending music from Deus Ex 1 or Ozar Midrashim from Legacy of Kain)
Oh and here is the link for the Indoctrination Theory if you didnt already know
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ythY_GkEBck
(waits for the comments that insult me for not playing it)
Done with that? good. Why i don't play it? my reasons are my own for not liking it, i am the kind of person that finds more interesting watching the Red Letter Media videos about Star Wars rather than watching the movies, specially his comparison of George Lucas to Charles Foster Kane of the Citizen Kane movie.
However i find the ending controversy of Mass Effect 3 interesting on his own for his "impact" on the gaming world. So lets start at the beginning in a very short but necessary butchering of the events that lead me to this point.
After hearing some superficial news about "dumbing down ME3" and "Gears of Effect" and "Day 1 DLC = RAAAAAAAAGE" i didn't actually though highly of the ME fanbase even if they may be right about EA following the leader and tampering the development of a RPG series.
Then the game came out and the complains about the endings reached this very forum, i read most of them and agreed that they were badly executed and rushed, and since i am not a fan i therefore don't know about the lore but judge the game on his own merits in the same way that Mr. Plinket judges how the Star Wars prequels failed as films FIRST and the rest later....
.......But then i read the "Indoctrination Theory" about the endings and i understood perfectly the situation, in fact, it seems deceptively easy to understand to the point of being just weird that no fan catched up instantly to what is going on (unlike me). The last minutes of the game have attention to detail that only a fan of the whole series would understand, after all this is why this trope exist:
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TheLawOfConservationOfDetail
So here lies the problem. If Bioware wanted to have a large amount of fans to notice the ending details then why would they alienate them so much to the point of having no fans but newcomers, playing the game and declaring that its ending sucks because obviously they havent been previously exposed to the kind of information that a fan would have? The way i see that most people complain about the ending makes me believe that they were newcomers (like me even if don't play) who complaining CONSTANTLY without being absolutely clear except for very few exceptions. A demographic that wouldn't have appeared if they hadn't dumbed down ME3 and tried to appeal as many people as possible, things that made your fanbase leave the sinking ship before even reaching the endings.
The result is an ending that nobody gets what is the deal about it because its meaning isn't for the new people, its for the fanbase that is no longer there for being alienated of the idea of having their "perfect" game being played by the evils of *!GASP!* CASUALS!!!
But the biggest punch in the balls is that if it wasn't for the Internet age then this "real" ending wouldn't be even on the works. No wait, i take that back, even with the Internet, if the developers had taken more time to answer the endings issue then the fan reaction would most likely be "Oooooh, it was intended all along, yeah suuuuuuuuure buddy. Don't even try to win us over after what you did, you fucking traitor"
Just the mere idea of gamers being THIS irrational and hateful makes me believe that other games had suffered trough this and its one of the many reasons that the developers eventually lose their hope for making a unique game. After all, if a massive response to the endings come from people who dont know anything about the series at all then its more likely that Bioware just give up completely and let EA take decisions for them 100%, why try to leave a mark on the world when the people cant even remember something on a previous game or even something that was shown right in their faces?
Maybe we have so little confidence on games today that even the idea of subtlety in details just escapes our comprehension. We need to lay off the hate before it we become the unwitting pawns of the destruction of all future games.
Thank you for your time.
(Bonus points if you read all this with the Dark Age ending music from Deus Ex 1 or Ozar Midrashim from Legacy of Kain)
Oh and here is the link for the Indoctrination Theory if you didnt already know
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ythY_GkEBck