teamcharlie said:
Jean-Claude Van Damme made some fantastic action movies and he's hardly the world's most talented actor. So, yes. I would absolutely cast Gina Carano in pretty much any role that calls for a woman who can believably punch out a grown man, especially because I am beyond tired of seeing a panoply of iterations of the same 19-year-old white waif with good skin play literally every female role in Hollywood.
So you don't care about character appropriate casting at all, then? Have you played the TR reboot or seen her design [http://sf.co.ua/13/03/wallpaper-2671701.jpg]? And you want to make
this era of Lara, what, a beefy 30-year-old Hispanic or something? I'd love to see, say, Michelle Rodriguez get more leading roles, ditto Katee Sackhoff who usually looks like she could hold her own. But we're talking casting an early 20's Lara, here... a Lara whose experience mostly pertains to
climbing Snowdon and backpacking with a friend.
And for me Van Damme's just an acting trainwreck, so gimme any proper actor over that guy. I don't want an 'action movie', either, I primarily want a character study for a new TR film. Probably won't ever
get that, but I live in [very mild] hope...
See: Shailene Woodley, Kristen Stewart, Jennifer Lawrence, Sophie Turner, Gal Godot, etc. There are other body types. There are tens of thousands of talented actresses in Hollywood of almost every body type practically dying to play a role in a movie. Let them!
For starters, Lawrence was criticised was being
too bulky/healthy looking for the role of Katniss, so making her some kind of meatheaded fighter would've been even more absurd than ignoring current Lara's design.
Personally I'd have definitely wanted a tougher, bulkier Woman Woman, but to be fair to various eras of her design she hasn't typically been depicted in that way, so Gal's not a terrible pick (I've heard she's pretty good in BvS).
Not sure why you're mentioning Sophie Turner. For Jean Grey, perhaps? If so, then that's a bizarre example given she's seemingly playing a young Jean with primarily
mental abilities. I'm assuming/hoping she won't be beating guys unconscious by punching them...
Never seen Shailene Woodley in anything, so I can't comment on how suitable she was per roles. As for Kristen Stewart? Snow White And The Huntsmen is the only proper physical role I've seen her in (pretty sure her character in Twilight only scraps when she's got vamp-powers), and you don't really need bulk to wear armour or swing a sword (her character's also more or less Pagan-Jesus. plus, she kinda sucks hard at fighting anyway... given her whole 'I'm going to throw my shield away at the final boss fight'-thing).