BlindChance said:
IF they made Penfold female and kept Penfold the snivelling, whiny, useless heap that he was in the original, I'd call that a total win. That'd be a very funny character in a way that female characters are not usually allowed to be. But I suspect they won't.
Ihateregistering1 said:
Anyway, I'd be curious to see what happens if they feminize Penfold, considering basically all he ever did was panic, be a coward, get kidnapped, and then need to be rescued by Danger Mouse, so I imagine many people would lose their shit if that character was female.
octafish said:
Could DM shush a Femfold as dismissively? I don't want a non-shushing DM.
Yeah, exactly these. The contemporary school of thought for writing female characters in kid's fiction/shows seems to be to make them strong, empowered, sassy women who emphatically "don't need no man", as a way of "correcting" historical gender stereotypes and avoiding giving offence. The problem is that this provides a very narrow range of roles these female characters can fit into, and the bumbling and most definitely subordinate Penfold is a role that would have "problematic" written all over it - we cant have a woman be a figure of fun, because it'd give the impression that women
in general are laughable; we can't have an incompetent female character because it'd give the impression that
all women are incompetent. The only avenue left would be to have a female sidekick who's inexplicably either more capable or intelligent than the male hero, and that's becoming a trope in itself.
A well-written female Penfold who wasn't gratuitously given the Girl Power treatment? That I'd be in favour of.
Also, Femfold is a brilliant name, even if it sounds vaguely pornographic.