Kopikatsu said:
Well, Straid is from Olaphis (Which stood where Drangleic does at one point) and Drangleic was also called Vinheim in the past. I forget where Navlaan is from, but I assume that it's also implied to be what was once Drangleic because he was presumed to have been killed, but in reality he simply imprisoned himself in Aldia's Keep.
The Knight set can't be from Lordran because the description says that it was made using special steel and techniques that were developed by Drangleic. Since Drangleic didn't exist when Lordran was around... I don't think that point in particular means much, considering you can find relics from halfway across the game world too. All it really says is that there are a ton of people drawn in by the curse (This time being controlled by Nashandra in hopes of finding a successor, but more on that later).
It's heavily implied that Vendrick stole either the Great Lord Souls or the First Flame itself (To be honest, I forget who says this. Maybe it was Chancellor Wellager after you beat the Giant Lord? Meh). Considering that the Great Lord Souls actually do make an appearance, I think it's a fairly reasonable to guess that those are what were taken. It's probable that Nashandra manipulated Vendrick into taking them in the first place so that she could distribute the Souls in hopes of finding a worthy successor to the Throne of Want (Which is her motivation for most of what she did). Nashandra herself says that the King was never worthy of the throne and never sat in it, which is why he's sealed away in the Undead Crypt (probably by Nashandra herself). It should be noted that the Throne of Want is directly tied to rekindling the flame according to the description for Vendrick's Soul.
As for the Giants themselves. They conquered Drangleic in retaliation for the King's sins, and either suffered extreme losses (unlikely) or simply returned to their homeland once Drangleic was in ruins (more likely, considering just how ridiculously more powerful the Giants are compared to Drangleic's forces as seen in the Memory segments). The Last Giant is possibly the Giant Lord himself judging by the description of the Last Giant's soul.
Both Seath and Nito are referenced by characters in the game, while Manus is..yeah. Seath by Manscorpion Tark and Nito by Grave Warden Agadayne, both referring to the creation of their respective 'races'. But the Four Lords once essentially ruled the world. So for their servants to be scattered around the world isn't too outlandish.
Good points. Could very easily be right. However, that shan't stop the wall of text...
I didn't catch anything about the area being Vinheim in the past, unless you're referencing the Lingering Dragoncrest Ring, which only says that it was "used in the land where Drangleic is now", not that it was "made" in the land where Drangleic is now.
And you're right, it's not too outlandish that their servants would be scattered over the world. I just don't really think it was, because I just went and had a chitchat with Tark and he said things like...
- "You've defeated
my master." // implying that it couldn't have been Seathe
- "But
our master will never die, only change forms."
He uses the phrase "seethe eternally", probably because he wants the player to draw the connection between Seethe and whatever created him (possibly Aldia, possibly the Duke).
Note: I don't know which boss I killed that prompted him to say these things/give me the Second Dragon Ring. I'd killed every boss except the Darklurker when I spoke to him, and I hadn't spoken to him since before Najka. So it is possible that he was referring to Najka as a sort of "She was my master because my life revolved around combat with her" type thing, but I can't be certain, and I don't know if he would reward you twice for the same boss kill.
But when he says that "our master will never die, only change forms", I think that lines up quite well with my theory that the Lord Souls are what drive the development of life in each Kingdom that rises and falls, since Seathe's soul would attach itself to some figure and influence him/her, much like he did with the Duke (or possibly Aldia). And it would still hold true that Seathe was his creator, just creating him in a different form than the Paledrake we all know and love (to kill).
Also, did Straid imprison himself? I know he has dialogue that discusses how the undead were shuttled away to (what I presume is) the Bastille (or did he mean Drangleic?) and that "they even petrified the great Straid" or something like that.
I don't mean that the Knight set is literally from Lordran, but I just think the fact that it looks exactly the same implies that Drangleic blacksmiths were crafting armour from Lordran, which would make it true that it was being developed with steel/techniques that were unique to Drangleic. Maybe it was just a fan-service thing, but without assumptions I have nothing to go off of.
I'm a bit of a derp and probably missed the info about the Giants invading Drangleic in retaliation to the King, but I was going off of the Giant Lord's Soul (since that's probably pretty accurate) when it said that they "conquered Drangleic [...] to claim an invaluable prize". I think the word choice is important here. It doesn't say anything about them retaliating, or taking what was stolen from them, or anything of the sort. It says the conquered Drangleic to claim a prize. The wording makes it sound like they invaded for new power, not to regain power. I personally think that Nashandra went to the King, told him to steal something from the Giants, then went and told the Giants about some immense power in Drangleic, prompting them to attack. I think she wanted the kingdom to crumble and fall for her own personal gain (the abyss, Age of Dark). This would make it so that everyone logically assumed that it was Vendrick's actions that brought down Drangleic, not Nashandra's. When she says that he's not fit for the Throne, maybe he started resisting her?
On his Ultra Greatsword, there's a likeness of the Queen on the back (sword is completely hideous by the way), and it says that "Only the king knows whether the depiction of the Queen is a resentful mockery, or an affectionate exaltation.". So maybe he started to realize his own manipulation and pulled away from her, prompting her to kill him and lock him away, knowing that he would never be useful. Quite rude, in my opinion.