HontooNoNeko said:
OT: Personally I cannot wait for this games release I loved Dark souls even if I never played Demons Souls and by the looks of the game play and the news I'm hearing this should be even better. This is especially good considering that I was never really bothered by the PC port and was willing to overlook low frame rate and poor optimization in light of just how well the game was designed. I may actually buy a game on release day as apposed to waiting for the price to go down in a long time for this.
If you ever get the chance, do yourself a favor and play Demon's Souls.
I know it can be kinda complicated, since it is only on PS3, but hey, the PS3 is great and it doesn't cost like a kidney anymore...
I think I may be in the minority here, but I find Demon's Souls to be considerably better than Dark Souls.
Dark Souls do have more varied and interesting environments, and enemy design, I'll give it that.
Nonetheless, I didn't like the change to a open world for the game (it kept the pacing a little weird, in comparison to Demon's Souls), I found the game to be too long (I have almost 100 hours in and still haven't finished the main quest, let alone tackle the DLC and optional areas), most bosses aren't very compelling (again, in comparison to Demon's Souls, in which most boss fights were very different from one another and tanking was rarely an viable solution), and I find Demon's Souls harder.
Demon's Souls is friggin' perfect.
I loved the Mega Man like choose-your-level-boss approach, and without sacrificing exploration and branching paths.
It is hard and the areas are dark and dilapidated, which builds up the tension and the mood.
It really felt like a good old Castelvania game (like rondo of blood), or Chakan (a great old Mega Drive game which deserved much more attention than it got).
I played it three times and I wish I had the time to platinum it (so close, though).
Not that Dark Souls is bad by any means. It is GREAT! I love the series so much that it reminds me why I got into videogames in the first place. Not for quick time events, not for prerendered cutscenes, or for explosive setpieces. Not even for compelling characters and story (sometimes it helps). Demon's/Dark Souls are a GAME, where gameplay and skill are what matters, and beating is an acheivement.
I just nitpicked it against (IMO) the better of the lot!