declared Non-Canon
- Thread starter I Max95
- Start date
Recommended Videos
See, this is why I tend to hate Star Wars EU sources with a passion. There is absolutely no quality control or fact checking, resulting in heinous inconsistencies and a complete lack of logic sometimes (the Republic only has three million clones to fight a galaxy-spanning conflict? Don't make me laugh). It only serves to divide the fanbase and confuses the newcomers.Flames66 said:
Screw 'em, they're all non-canon in my book (except the X-Wing books, Zahn's Thrawn trilogy, and the Han Solo Adventures).
Why? I've read about what she's introduced (a friend showed me a list) and the stuff on there is just agressively awful.Flames66 said:
What doesn't make sense is taking the name Star Trek off of it at one point so it would appeal to others. I loved the Dark Mirror episodes though, it showed how good that show could've been.badgersprite said:
I did love GT though.
I may have misinterpreted the implication, but I thought that the idea was that the Baudelaire Children were able to live comfortably alone and away from all the chaos that has faced their lives. The fact that everything else went unaddressed and we were left without knowing much beyond this ending for the Baudelaire Children which, to me, seemed to be a relatively cheery end.emeraldrafael said:
Kingdom Hearts Re: Chain of Memories... there's nothing between the first and second games. Not at all. O__o
well, maybe I was wrong then. I just didnt see it as positive when.. well.. nah, we ruined the book's ending already. I didnt see it as happy when Kit (?) was pushed out to sea to die.Feste the Jester said:
I'm of the mind that Dr.Eggman is the non-canon imposter.Atticus89 said:
I was a confused 10 year old when sonic shouted - "Oh no, Eggman is getting away!"
my reply - "Is that a new nickname for Dr.Robotnik?"
Sonic adventure was fun but HIS NAME IS ROBOTNIK DAMMIT.
oh deez video gaems, man.
Just because a show has no regard for linear time does not make any particular part non-canon. Canon is simply that which is accepted as being an official part of a package. There are non-canon episodes of the Simpsons. For example, each haloween special as it is accepted that the events portrayed did not occur in the same universe as the normal events of the show.emeraldrafael said:
There is ONLY one.Rathcoole said:
Sorry, just had to say it.
OT: I would like to say "Sonic since Sonic vs. Knuckles" but Sonic has one of the most $@#%ed up canons in video games so I have no idea what even begins to "count."
Chrono Cross.
A lot of people really, really liked that game, which is great. But I lost interest after three hours and was soon horrified to discover it turns the entire plot of Chrono Trigger (which I loved) into an enormous "Nice Job Breaking It, Hero" - see TVtropes, if you have six hours to kill.
And, um, then Cross murders or implies the murder of about half of the PCs from Trigger. Most of them are killed off-screen; the notable exception to that is killed within about four lines of his introduction. It doesn't help that cuts resulted in the most interesting bits of Cross's story, such as the return of Magus from Trigger, being removed from the game.
So yeah. Many adore it, but I simply loathe Chrono Cross.
Oh, and also there were no sequels to the Matrix and only three Star Wars movies.
A lot of people really, really liked that game, which is great. But I lost interest after three hours and was soon horrified to discover it turns the entire plot of Chrono Trigger (which I loved) into an enormous "Nice Job Breaking It, Hero" - see TVtropes, if you have six hours to kill.
And, um, then Cross murders or implies the murder of about half of the PCs from Trigger. Most of them are killed off-screen; the notable exception to that is killed within about four lines of his introduction. It doesn't help that cuts resulted in the most interesting bits of Cross's story, such as the return of Magus from Trigger, being removed from the game.
So yeah. Many adore it, but I simply loathe Chrono Cross.
Oh, and also there were no sequels to the Matrix and only three Star Wars movies.
I dunno, I thought that Stargate SG-1's two hundredth episode "200" was pretty darn awesome.emeraldrafael said:
<youtube=g9XrrEaZ7Y4>
Seems about accurate.
True, that Ori thing kinda had potencial, but the episodes were getting really boring and Richard Dead Anderson was a great loss to the show, didn't help the fact that guy who replace him a less funny clone.kahlzun said: