The Princess Bride (6/10)
This is going to turn some heads, but I can't say I'm that impressed with this film. As quotable as it is in individual moments, as a whole? Eh...
Anyway, random thoughts going through it:
-Buttercup is terrible, and Wesley can do a lot better. Her relationship begins with her treating him like dirt, but hey, 'true wuv.' And I might buy that if Buttercup actually had anything approaching a character arc, but no, she does nothing in the movie but be rescued, or when she's given up hope of being rescued, decides to commit suicide. Supposedly, this film (and the book) is a spoof on romance/princess tropes, but I'm not sure what it's spoofing, because it plays it all straight. TL, DR, Buttercup is terrible, and Wesley is wasting his time on her. Also, I get that Westley is hiding his persona from Buttercup to see if she truly loves him still, but she never actually gives a straight answer before the reveal.
-I know this is beside the point, but can I comment how the setting of the, um, setting, makes no sense? We have the town of "Florin" (which I assume is a spoof on Florence), and therefore in Italy, yet nothing we see in or around Florin shows any sense of Italian geography, language, or culture. Furthermore, Australia is mentioned as being a country of criminals, so this must take place sometime after 1788, but the level of technology on display is Medieval. I know, it's not trying to be realistic, but come on, seriously?
-I'll give credit to the duel between Westley and Inigo as being simultaniously badass, hilarious, and well-choreographed all at once. That said, I'm left to ask two things. One, Inigo has been practicing fencing for 20 years, while Westley has, at best, practiced for 5, yet Westley bests him. Second, Westley adopted the persona of Dread Pirate Roberts for at least some of that time, so...how many people has he killed since then? It's stated clearly that Dread Pirate Roberts leaves no survivours, and that Westley is the one exception for the original DPR.
Also, DPR's been scouring the seas for over 50 years, so did anyone wonder about how he could keep it up so long? Then again, there does seem to be a supernatural element to the myth as seen at the end, so I guess that doesn't matter too much.
-I'll give credit to Humperdinck as a villain that's slowly revealed to be a villain and all that. Makes Buttercup look all the more stupid (why yes, I WILL trust this git to send out boats to find my 'true wuv,' despite the fact that I'm being married against my will), but he's okay.
-Moving on from that, there's contrivances galore. Inigo just happens to be in the right forest at the right time, and Fezzik just happens to turn up at the right time for him, and they just happen to be at the right tree that will lead them to Wesley, and there just happens to be someone who can bring him back to life, and they just happen to have a magic cloak that will get them entry into the castle. I know, parody, but still, two words. Chekov's. Gun.
-So Inigo duels the man who killed his father through magical means. I say magical because he gets a knife to his stomach and multiple stab wounds, but then plougs through it and kills the count with a stomach wound, which does kill him, whereas he wasn't killed earlier. Um, sure.
-I'll give credit to the "to the pain" speech.
-So they all live happily ever after (except Vizzini...I kept expecting him to show up, before realizing that he was, indeed, dead), and Inigo may go on to be Dread Pirate Roberts (ergo, a murderer who leaves no survivours), and Westley and Buttercup have 'true wuv's kiss', because Buttercup is still terrible, and Westley still doesn't realize it). And...yay. Story's over.
-Overall, there's individual moments in the movie that had me grinning, but as a whole? It's an average fantasy-adventure-comedy flick. Decent, but I've no idea why it's as beloved as it is.