This sounds way more interesting than I would have given it credit for. I had no intention of ever watching it, even if it comes to a streaming channel I subscribe to. With your description? Sounds like something worth experiencing.
I am surprised it didn't do better. I've seen some pretty meh movies about the creative industries (most recently the decidedly meh "Tick Tick Boom") that the critics loved as, they seem to love movies about their industry.
I like movies about the industry too. Babylon is definitely worth experiencing. It has top notch production value and knows how to be funny/creepy/sad. Even though parts dragged I was never really bored in a little over 3 hours. And I also have a vested interest in the older history of Hollywood, since I studied all this some ways back, meaning I get to be both nostalgic for a time in history as much as for a specific time in my life.
Here's what: as much as I admire his craft and like his movies I don't agree with Damien Chazelle's cynical worldview about having to self-destruct in order to produce anything worthwhile. And where this applied to one or two people striving for perfection in Whiplash and La La Land, here the implication is that all of Hollywood had to burn through thousands of lives and lesser movies in order to achieve the 'perfection' of a handful of classics, somehow justifying the misery throughout. This to me also devalues the output of the silent era, reducing it to an immature phase that the industry had to outgrow before it achieved the perfection of (cue emotional movie reel).
This in turn I associate with the faux progressive fad of depicting the protagonist/s of your movie as victims who have no agency, are at the mercy of circumstance and any one success is downplayed almost apologetically.
Here's how an Amelia Earhart biopic would play out today:
- She was probably abused.
- She was definitely bullied and opposed by every person she ever met or wouldn't have achieved anything worthwhile.
- Flying planes would be her form of coping with abuse etc.
- Movie starts with her probably sick of flying planes.
- She should've been more socially aware than she was.
- She wasn't even that good at flying planes.
- She rediscovers her passion begrudgingly.
- Her achievements were a fluke that were crucially co-authored by some unsung other.
- Poor Amelia, victim of a tortured psyche.
- And because she rose above victimhood she's worth celebrating.
Narc over.