Rise of the Guardians, 5/10
I'd been somewhat curious about this movie, and it's got Santa in it, so I figured why not, 'tis the season after all. Stunningly generic title aside, this movie's actually got a pretty original premise, best summarised as "childhood fairytales as superheroes". It's got Jack Frost, the Sandman (sadly not the cool Neil Gaiman type), the Tooth Fairy, Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny acting as an Avengers-esque team protecting the innocence and joy of children. But when The Boogeyman (played quite delightfully by Jude Law) makes his comeback, it's up to the team to stop him.
Sadly the movie is almost as generic as its title. Despite the multitude of things going for it, it ends up being a very by the numbers family film. But I wanna focus on the positives first: the Boogeyman is actually a pretty cool villain, being a bit of a snarky, smug dickhead. But he's also allowed to be vulnerable and have a degree of depth, he's not just a generic dark bad villain. He and Jack Frost have a decent dynamic, having more in common with each other than they'd like to admit. There's some quite interesting visual design and ideas as well: Easter egg golems, the Tooth Fairy being a hummingbird for some reason, the Sandman having zero dialogue for example. Jack Frost also has quite an intriguing mystery related to him, which the payoff sadly doesn't live up to.
But the movie altogether ends up being just mediocre, and I'm not meaning that this could have been a great movie to begin with. It just suffers from classic problems like pacing issues, trying to do too much in just about 90 minutes, and not having the balls to go as dark as you could or be as creative as you could. The villain is probably the best example of both: you could do so much interesting and creepy visual stuff with a villain who's supposed to represent fear of the dark and the monsters under your bed. You could have him appear only as a shadow, or only in the darkest parts of the screen, or as an unseen presence until the very end. He could have been so creepy and memorable. But no, he's just a monochromatic snarky dude who only occasionally has some visual flair, despite Jude Law clearly having fun with the role. Jack Frost has this mystery about his identity which is actually built up really well with an almost eldritch element relating to the moon, but it's revealed he's just some random fuck named Jack who fell into a frozen pond, which is just super disappointing. You could have had him be revealed to be Jack from Jack the Beanstalk for example, that could have been cool.
The pacing feels rushed in exactly the way a lot of animated family films feel. There's very limited moments of silence of slowness, character arcs and dynamics feel superficial and the movie feels it's never allowed to breathe. In trying to characterize 5 main characters and getting through the plot in about 90 minutes it ends up feeling like skimming the surface of what could genuinely be a really interesting mythology and world. This concept would be right at home as a streaming service animated show, because the glimpses of what we do see and hear hint at a whole world of possible adventures. Chris Pine is hopelessly miscast. His performance isn't bad, but the mismatch between his voice and the design of Jack Frost prevents it from ever jeling naturally.
The movie also just feels dated in quite a lot of ways. Despite this being from 2012 (meaning after Toy Story 3, which still looks like a billion bucks), the CG looks quite dated: the designs are bland, some of the lighting is kind of ehhh, and the look of the movie overall is just quite flat and dull. This was smack dab in the middle of Hollywood's 3D push, so there's tons of scenes which you can clearly tell were made with 3D in mind. It's also got this annoying element which feels specific to animated films of this era, which I could call "setpieces of pointless bullshit". Meaning that multiple times the movie will suddenly make an exciting scene out of something that doesn't forward the story at all, and is there only to tokenly give some excitement for the kids. For example, when they first leave the North Pole in Santa's sleigh, their departure is this like 30-second long scene where the camera is swooshing and wooshing and characters are going "whooo", but all that's really happening is them doing the equivalent of getting off a driveway. It just gives off an air of desperate pandering where the movie is just jingling keys in front of you to keep your attention.
So yeah, pretty bland and forgettable overall. Dreamworks were clearly angling for a franchise with this since both Madagascar and Shrek were over (sans the ciriminally underrated Penguins of Madagascar movie), but it was a pretty big box office bomb, losing some $70 million. But hey, if this was one of the stepping stones on the way to modern Dreamworks which eventually gave us The Last Wish, The Bad Guys and The Wild Robot, I'm not too mad about it. This is still a film where people clearly cared, and that's always something.