Just got back from watching Return to Silent Hill.
Honestly, if you've never played Silent Hill 2, like the friend I went to see it with, you might get something out of it. The story's about as subtle as a brick to the face and it may have gone through one rewrite too many, but the acting (especially the physical acting from Jeremy Irvine [James] and the monster actors) and cinematography are really good. Knowing the original (or at least the remake), though, that lack of subtlety really hurt it, and maybe this is just a 'clash of expectations' thing, but I feel like the story they came up with whole cloth for the movie was a lot less interesting than the game's.
I don't know how many people on a primarily-gaming forum wouldn't have played or have any interest in Silent Hill 2, but would see a movie based on it anyway, but there you go. It's definitely not a movie I regret seeing, per se, but I wouldn't see it again.
Honestly, if you've never played Silent Hill 2, like the friend I went to see it with, you might get something out of it. The story's about as subtle as a brick to the face and it may have gone through one rewrite too many, but the acting (especially the physical acting from Jeremy Irvine [James] and the monster actors) and cinematography are really good. Knowing the original (or at least the remake), though, that lack of subtlety really hurt it, and maybe this is just a 'clash of expectations' thing, but I feel like the story they came up with whole cloth for the movie was a lot less interesting than the game's.
I don't know how many people on a primarily-gaming forum wouldn't have played or have any interest in Silent Hill 2, but would see a movie based on it anyway, but there you go. It's definitely not a movie I regret seeing, per se, but I wouldn't see it again.