Well evil is a subjective concept, therefore everyone will have their own opinions about this matter. Personally, I believe that there is no such thing as evil, just a misunderstanding or lack of information regarding a person's actions. However, there are some actions that are considered to be "bad" based on societal norms but that is, again, a subjective concept.
Really there is no way to define evil or bad (or good) non subjectively unless we take it down to it's base: does it cause any kind of harm to another individual or not in any way shape or form? If so, then it should be considered to be a "bad" action. If it does not cause any form of harm it's "good". And now we're left with the same dilemma. Where is the line between merely "bad" and "evil"? As I've stated before I believe that there is no such thing as evil due to the subjective nature of the classification of an action as "evil".
In your situation there is no context. Either one of those individuals could have been held captive for years as a child suffering through rape and other forms of physical and psychological abuse that scarred them for life and left serious developmental problems. Therefore it is impossible to judge these two individuals and tell you if they are in fact "evil".
Really there is no way to define evil or bad (or good) non subjectively unless we take it down to it's base: does it cause any kind of harm to another individual or not in any way shape or form? If so, then it should be considered to be a "bad" action. If it does not cause any form of harm it's "good". And now we're left with the same dilemma. Where is the line between merely "bad" and "evil"? As I've stated before I believe that there is no such thing as evil due to the subjective nature of the classification of an action as "evil".
In your situation there is no context. Either one of those individuals could have been held captive for years as a child suffering through rape and other forms of physical and psychological abuse that scarred them for life and left serious developmental problems. Therefore it is impossible to judge these two individuals and tell you if they are in fact "evil".