Do you enjoy cutscenes?
- Thread starter Legion IV
- Start date
Recommended Videos
Depends on a few things. If the voice acting annoys me, I skip. If it does nothing but show combat/fighting that I should be doing, I skip. If the story is uninteresting, I skip, etc, etc. You get the point.
I try to only watch good cutscenes, my favorites being most from BioWare games, because they have you actually interacting and making decisions in them. If I wanted to watch people dick about with no input from myself, I could just as easily watch a movie or TV.
I try to only watch good cutscenes, my favorites being most from BioWare games, because they have you actually interacting and making decisions in them. If I wanted to watch people dick about with no input from myself, I could just as easily watch a movie or TV.
Depends on the game. I didn't really notice that I wasn't playing the fight in DMC4 simply because, really, the main character only got up and fought for a few seconds before you got control, and that was pretty bad ass. But I also saw the Onimusha 3 prologue (through Unskipable, naturally), and the way the entire cutscene played out actually looked like a level design. There were goons, slightly harder goons, platforming, and a boss fight.
I usually like cutscenes, it helps engross me in the game whether or not they're good, but if the first cutscene is a ten minute fight scene... meh.
PS, You should probably know not to take Yahtzee too seriously. He has his opinion, generally saying they're bad, but the only reviews he's ever done that should sway someone's opinion is when he says something's good. If he says it's bad, it's probably decent.
I usually like cutscenes, it helps engross me in the game whether or not they're good, but if the first cutscene is a ten minute fight scene... meh.
PS, You should probably know not to take Yahtzee too seriously. He has his opinion, generally saying they're bad, but the only reviews he's ever done that should sway someone's opinion is when he says something's good. If he says it's bad, it's probably decent.
Yes I do, when they are well scripted and interesting to watch. Good cutscenes can be very immersive for a game. Personally, I don't even mind cutscene spam like MGS4.
When I see a kickass fight cutscene and I'm not allowed to do any of that stuff in actual gameplay, then I hate it.
I don't play SP games much, and the ones I do don't have many cutscenes.
When they're solely to drive storyline, I love them.
When they solely have action, I'm a bit disappointed I can'y play it, but then realise that gameplay mechanics for THAT stuff would suck anyways, and like them again.
When they drive the storyline AND have action, I fucking hate them.
When they just show a place or do a 360 view or something, I lose interest in the game and play Sauerbraten instead.
When they're solely to drive storyline, I love them.
When they solely have action, I'm a bit disappointed I can'y play it, but then realise that gameplay mechanics for THAT stuff would suck anyways, and like them again.
When they drive the storyline AND have action, I fucking hate them.
When they just show a place or do a 360 view or something, I lose interest in the game and play Sauerbraten instead.
Some like the Soul Reaver 2 intro are brilliant, but when its just pointless talking and nothing plot significant or interesting happens then they can be crap.
Hate them. I'd rather read through the text in the chat log after skipping through the cutscene as quickly as possible, and too many forced cutscenes have led me to uninstall games. Hate them, hate them, hate them. I don't buy games to watch them, I buy them to play. When dialog options are woven into the cutscene that's even worse, because then I have to have it playing at least long enough to read the text to know how I want to reply.
That's the reason I never really enjoyed replaying Assassin's Creed. The game is great (although my computer had some performance issues regarding lip synch), but the lengthy unskippable cutscenes just piss me off...Thunderhorse31 said:
Anyway, I enjoy cutscenes if they are well-made and not mandatory.
Generally no, because all too often even if the plot is engaging they are horribly written.
MGS is an exception, it may be cheesy but the banter is engaging, it is dynamically presented and the voice actors deliver with aplomb.
Far too many cutscenes in other games are just full of boring banal exposition, but the worst ones are those filled with action... couldn't I be doing the fighting rather than have control wrenched from me? And the fighting is rarely even good enough to justify the loss of control as the chances that a developers is both a good game designer AND a good action movie director... most of the time you don't have both.
MGS is an exception, it may be cheesy but the banter is engaging, it is dynamically presented and the voice actors deliver with aplomb.
Far too many cutscenes in other games are just full of boring banal exposition, but the worst ones are those filled with action... couldn't I be doing the fighting rather than have control wrenched from me? And the fighting is rarely even good enough to justify the loss of control as the chances that a developers is both a good game designer AND a good action movie director... most of the time you don't have both.
I love cutscenes.
They are always a nice little break, they might let you know when a level is over, or when you are coming up to a boss, or just for some story. Unskippable ones are kind of annoying though.
But ya, the DMC cutscenes are always fun to watch, they are full of ham, and ham deserves to be watched.
They are always a nice little break, they might let you know when a level is over, or when you are coming up to a boss, or just for some story. Unskippable ones are kind of annoying though.
But ya, the DMC cutscenes are always fun to watch, they are full of ham, and ham deserves to be watched.
That's just a lie.Legion IV said:
Cutscenes are tough, and a question like "Do you enjoy cutscenes" is pretty weird right off the bad. It's like saying "Do you like instruction manuals. /analogy.
The problem I have with cutscenes is that they are the worst way to engross you in a game. They are the moment where the game ceases to be a game. They wrest control away from you and suddenly start playing at being movies.
In the developer commentary from one of the cutscenes from Jak 3 (Because I LISTEN to crap like that) they said that the cutscene must create a mood, tell the story, but most importantly, it has to tell the player what to do. The problem isn't just "why can't I do that cool stuff that my character is doing?" but it's also "Why did my game stop being a game."
That said, I enjoy the crap out of them when they're done right. I don't like them in DMC, but not because I wish I could do that awesome stuff, I don't like them in DMC because I don't like getting the sense that the game is impressed with itself. And that bombastic action just seems like it's compensating for something. In the final fantasy games they're great because "looking at pretty things happening" is sort of what I'm in it for.
But if it's all the same to video game developers, can we just all do what Valve does and figure out a way to tell the story without pressing pause on me? Or even the Assassin's Creed version where you totally pretend like the player has control but they super don't.
