It'll be a shame in some ways, but I've seen it coming for a while now. The low comment counts on the featured articles, the dwindling article counts in the individual issues, the increasing familiarity of the writers - this has been a while in coming.
In September 2005 I found the PDFs of the first 4 issues of The Escapist on a physical magazine cover DVD. I read every one of them cover to cover, over and over again, entranced at just how thought-provoking they all were. I eventually stopped buying the aforementioned physical magazine in favour of reading The Escapist, because I was far more interested in articles and opinions than reviews and previews.
I skipped a whole bunch of issues in between issue 4 and 185 or so, due to the unavailability of internet, but I've read most every issue since then. I'm going to miss reading through the magazine with a coffee every Tuesday afternoon, but that's just how it'll have to be. If changing things around is the way to bring the readers more excellent content, then I can't really complain.
In a way, the change sort of mirrors the way my usage of this site has change. In the past, I came here every Tuesday and read the magazine, but as I explored the site more, I became interested in the columns, the videos, and all the other miscellaneous stuff you guys have to offer. Now I visit The Escapist at least daily!
However, it might be nice if you kept the current issue page, and collected the week's feature articles and other notable things on it - that way binge readers like myself could sit down and read the week's content all in one go on a Sunday (or even the following Tuesday!).
Whatever you end up doing, I'm excited to see the results!