This article is really ancient in Internet chronology... The escapist is a completely different place to what it was then. Now-a-days this place (speaking only about the forums) isn't much different than the gamespot or ign forums, just better organised and much higher standards of moderation. Most of the users take pride in this but the old days of snooty elitism are pretty much gone by my reckoning...
Ever since Vs threads, list threads and the endless ask a _____ threads suddenly became kosher, the ratio of good to bad threads reached critical mass. There simply isn't space or time for elitism now.
Still, I do enjoy these forums the most, but there's no way a forum this big/busy can be called the best on the web with a straight face...