Luca72 said:
What do you find good about it, OP? I've seen videos that look cool, and I like the setting, but I tend to hear a community response like the one in this topic. Sounds like it has it's fair share of problems.
But it's not that hard to sell me on an excuse to blast cyberpunk corporate ninjas in Source
I think it depends on what you're looking for in a game.
The narrative is inconsequential and just plain context at best, and incomprehensibly jumpy at worst.
The gameplay is brutal, massively complex, and barely explained, but fun once you get the handle of it. Leveling is even more complicated and even less explained, though common sense can dictate most of the more basic things.
And while my word may not be the best to go off of since I thought
Amnesia: The Dark Descent was a pretty decent-looking game, it looks rather awe-striking considering the assets they had to work with.
It's definitely not polished. If you would expect to jump in and immediately know where you're going, what you're doing, and how to get there, it'll probably leave you extremely confused and disappointed. And you could pretty much forget about trying to play in a stealthy manner too, unless some of the later abilities heavily augment it.
I suppose in a way it's sort of like the
Demon's Souls of first-person shooters, and by that token I'd recommend it to people who think they can muscle their way past unexplained mechanics and clunky interfaces to find the chasm of depth hidden behind it all.