Fallout 4 Has Sold 12 Million Copies

[Reasonable Atheist]

I love that my hand is not being held
[...]
I love how quests can go totally different directions and have effects on multiple characters and events depending what you do (looking at you telltale)

Oh yes, I love how I'm able to shoot people in the face and tell them I hate them, only for them to idolize me later on anyway and offer sex-on-demand after a charisma check(I hate Piper).

The only reason they're not holding you by your hand, is because they're dragging you by your feet.

What, you would prefer it to be like dark souls? One accidental keystroke and piper never speaks to you again? Its a game, piper is not a woman.

I have accidentally hit my companion characters with machetes, shot them in the chest by mistake while trying to skip dialog and the game is like "its cool man we get it, no need to reload over that"

Thanks for pointing out something else i love about fallout 4

Ps. I like piper, shes a tough cookie. I especially like her dialogue with the supermutant "strong" but then again all of strong's dialogue is great.

 

[Naqel]

What, you would prefer it to be like dark souls? One accidental keystroke and piper never speaks to you again? [...]
I have accidentally hit my companion characters with machetes, shot them in the chest by mistake while trying to skip dialog and the game is like "its cool man we get it, no need to reload over that"

There's a perk to prevent you from being able to inflict damage to your active companion.

Under all other circumstances, I should be able to make them hate me, I should be free to kill them, and that extends to all the NPC's.
I should be allowed to make mistakes, and for those mistakes to have consequences.

In Fallout 4, you are not allowed to make mistakes, and your experience is inherently poorer for it.

 

[Reasonable Atheist]

What, you would prefer it to be like dark souls? One accidental keystroke and piper never speaks to you again? [...]
I have accidentally hit my companion characters with machetes, shot them in the chest by mistake while trying to skip dialog and the game is like "its cool man we get it, no need to reload over that"

There's a perk to prevent you from being able to inflict damage to your active companion.

Under all other circumstances, I should be able to make them hate me, I should be free to kill them, and that extends to all the NPC's.
I should be allowed to make mistakes, and for those mistakes to have consequences.

In Fallout 4, you are not allowed to make mistakes, and your experience is inherently poorer for it.

If you want piper to hate you, try being a little more creative, stealing or killing the innocent (or who she perceives as innocent) wull build disdain for you from piper