Why would you have to hand in your man-card for that? It's the only good romance novel out there.Eleuthera said:I assume I will have to hand my man-card in (again) for this. But my all time favourite book is "Pride and Prejudice".
Because we are MEN[sup]tm[/sup] *flex* GRRR, we are not to like romance... or something like that, I wasn't paying attention when they handed out the man-cards...lacktheknack said:Why would you have to hand in your man-card for that? It's the only good romance novel out there.
My favourite book of all time is Bilbo. Personally I think he is a fairly good writer, certainly not the best, but he makes up for it with good world building.Rylot said:Does anyone really consider Tolkien's work to be their favorite? He did some amazing world building and indelibly left his mark on modern fantasy but a good writer he was not.
See, the thing is that most people haven't read the classics, which is why I bothered making the comment. But, like I said, I don't know what I was expecting. The thing that got to me was all the pulp fiction and teen-trash books people were posting like The Hunger Games. That really shouldn't have bothered me though, considering I'm posting on a video game forum, which is easily the trashiest and least intellectually stimulating form of media existing, so the average person on here really wouldn't be reading James Joyce I guess. Especially since the Escapist's descent into a majority of people under 18.Stasisesque said:Remarks like this always confuse me. What exactly disappoints you? That the majority of people here prefer fantasy to period drama? That you don't recognise many of them to be classics? Or that people aren't listing enough books (or wearing enough hats)?Westaway said:Man, not sure what I expected but after browsing a few of the posts I'm disappointed in the Escapist. Do you guys even READ?
I would suggest pretty much everyone here has read the classics, if not for pleasure, then at least for school. Not listing them as their favourites has no bearing on whether or not they enjoyed them. And wouldn't it be rather boring if every post listed the same selection of books? True, there's very little diversity in terms of genre going on here, but that excludes those who flat-out dislike science fiction or fantasy novels; for everyone else this thread must be a goldmine of opportunity.
I'm sorry if this comes across as confrontational, I'm just disappointed people criticise each other for the type of fiction they enjoy.
To be honest I despised that novel. To me, Holden was unbarable to listen to. He was just a whiny pile of angst. Then again that was kind of the point of his character, so if you like angst than I guess that book is perfect for you.Relish in Chaos said:The Catcher in the Rye, because I find the main character immediately relatable and I just like the unique writing style.