Fictional people you'd dump your girlfriend for

[Paragon Fury]

Lets see now....the abbreviated list.

Lightning Farron

Spoiler

Isane Kotetsu

Spoiler

Tiger

Spoiler

Tina or Ayane (If she were a bit older)

Spoiler

 

[Ladette]

Spoiler

Utterly loyal, super powers, the ability to summon a flying pony. That'd be pretty hard to pass up.

 

[chuckman1]

Look at my avatar, Lucy from Elfen Lied

Spoiler: I'd have to be REALLY careful not to piss her off

My girlfriend refuses to dye her hair, wear/grow horns...
This leaves me disgruntled.

I would probably agree though I might go with Nyu so I wouldn't have to worry about my limbs flying apart if I piss her off.

 

[The Scythian]

Fictional, huh? Then the choice is clear: Aphrodite. I could literally never be disapointed.

 

[Z of the Na'vi]

There is one, and only one fictional woman I would ever, ever trade my girlfriend for.

[small]Hah, couldn't say that with a straight face. I don't have a girlfriend. Haven't since Junior High. Who needs 'em.

...*sniff*...[/small]

Anyway...

Spoiler: Prepare to be surprised.

Look at her. She's adorable.

 

[Trivun]

Rena Ryugu.
Lucy (Elfen Lied).
Luna Lovegood.
Alice (from the play/film Closer).
April Ryan.
Lisa Miller/Ramona Flowers/Kim Pine.

I would most certainly pursue all of them if they were real. I have a thing for indie girls, psycho girls, and vulnerable unstable girls...

 

[Wuffykins]

That's easy!

The Doctor (Mcsexypants #10 to be precise), no question at all.

In fact this actually came up in conversation with a previous girlfriend, and though it did hit an awkward tone here and there, it was mutually decided upon that, in the unlikely event of the TARDIS materialising in front of us while walking together, the relationship would be declared void and may the best boy/girl win.

Beyond that, I guess I should mention that Celes Chere and Kitty Pryde might be able to do the same.

 

[xdom125x]

I will try to avoid live-action characters because I think any attraction I have to them is probably more towards the actress playing them.

In no specific order (really it is just the order that I thought of them in):
1) Huntress
2) Bayonetta
3) Samus Aran
4) Suki, 5)Mai and 6)Ty Lee from Avatar:tla. It would be pretty awesome if I could get a reality/fiction barrier breaking polygamist relationship with these ladies.(help me Obi Wan Kenobi internet wizards, you're my only hope)



This is of course, operating off of the bold assumption that I even have a girlfriend to sacrifice.

Edit: thanks to reading other people's examples and viewing a certain person's avatar, I have come back to add:
7) Starfire
8) Harley Quinn
9) Ramona Flowers

 

[dibblywibbles]

There's a couple I'm sure. I'm thinking Celes from Final Fantasy 3/6. She can suck up any magic attacks thrown at me, she's a caregiver and seems so fragile and strong at the same time it just melts the heart. not like that freak half breed Terra. Just get that dirty bandit Locke out of the way and we're golden! After you save the world it's time to settle down with a good, caring and honest man...and I'm close enough.

 

[AnkaraTheFallen]

I can't think of anyone I'd leave my girlfriend for... that said, I'd be open to letting others join if with our fun if she was up for it to ;P

Fictional, huh? Then the choice is clear: Aphrodite. I could literally never be disapointed.

Haha, yup, This would be one of my choices.

 

[Kuranesno7]

open relationship between Glados and Shodan. I always had a thing for smart women with pitch-black senses of humor who are a lttle crazy.

 

[Wolfram23]

No, because they're never fleshed out enough to know what they're like, whereas I love my girlfriend.

Buuut let's say things go sour and I get to go on a date, I guess either Samus Aran or Alex (HL2). Well, that or Bayonetta bow chika bow wow.

 

[ReservoirAngel]

Spoiler: ANY character played by Thomas Sangster in the past couple of years, with some exceptions

ANY character played by Thomas Sangster in the past couple of years, with some exception

 

[garfoldsomeoneelse]

Not a terribly original answer, but if Alyx Vance was on the market, I'd swoop on her like an owl on a field mouse. She's outdoorsy, athletic, extroverted, confident, highly competent, and seems both stable and independent enough to avoid being clingy or needy. She seems to be the type that would be into most of the things I enjoy (hiking, biking, gym-ratting, shooting sports, might even share my taste in music if lightning strikes thrice). She's also got the whole mixed-race thing going on, which is nice but is really just a small bonus* in the grand scheme of things.

[sub]*By small bonus, I mean enormous, gigantic plus. Lord in heaven, do I love me some exotic strange. My seed craves foreign soil.[/sub]

 

[SckizoBoy]

Fictional, huh? Then the choice is clear: Aphrodite. I could literally never be disapointed.

You sure? Be certain not to let your eyes even so much as wonder across another woman, Aphrodite can be a right vindictive ***** at times.

Lets see now....the abbreviated list.

Lightning Farron

Spoiler

Isane Kotetsu

Spoiler

Tiger

Spoiler

Tina or Ayane (If she were a bit older)

Spoiler

Ehm, anyone else see a slight pattern here? Hmmmmm?

OT: Celty from Durarara (if only for Miyuki Sawashiro's voice...)

...

...

*hrk*

 

[NeutralDrow]

Even with the promise of not hurting their feelings, that sounds rather out-of-character for me. But still...

Probably Falsita from Symphonic Rain. God have mercy on my soul, I kinda already fell in love with her while playing the game...likely because she reminded me so much of my ex-girlfriend. Of course, that twist near the end throws the idea into question.

 

[gazumped]

I'm not saying I would, but I'd probably give it some serious consideration...

Spoiler: My first love.

Nightcrawler, but the X-Men: Evolution version

He was... uh... my imaginary boyfriend from when I was 12 to when I was 14. I was so obsessed with him I told everyone I was seeing a German boy called Kurt who dyed his hair blue.

I had to come clean about it to my mum when she started crying one evening, saying I must be ashamed of her because I never brought Kurt to my house.

... This isn't even a joke. :/

 

[Not-here-anymore]

Hmm... Either Starfire or Ramona Flowers, I guess.

Though both of them are quite similar to my girlfriend in a fair few ways. (hopefully that doesn't extend to evil ex-boyfriends. Mostly because I'm too lazy to fight them)

 

[Brandon237]

None, my girlfriend is awesome and doesn't have any of those strange personalities that most fictional characters have. So not happening.

 

[loc978]

Can't really think of one who would have the all important factor of focused nymphomania combined with the sort of intelligence I can hold a conversation with.
Think I'll stick with what I've got.