FreelanceButler said:
Apparently I'm in a massive minority here, but I thought XIII was pretty good, battle system and all. Maybe it's because I like the story so much I'm blotting out the bad points but, for the time being, I like it.
Couldn't they leave the Kingdom Hearts style gameplay to Kingdom Hearts? I thought XII was the attempt of fusing the two, and I just couldn't get the hang of it.
There does seem to be an awful lot of hate for XIII.
Now, I'm opening myself to veteran FF fans here, but I've never played another Final Fantasy game until 13. I can't say how it compares as a Final Fantasy game, because I don't know other Final Fantasy games. That may be why I find it good, I don't know.
Anyway, I found the game to be incredible. The locations, yes, were linear, but I'd rather play a linear game where things are to the point rather than a sprawling behemoth of a world where you could easily get lost for a while. The locations are also absolutely stunning. Lake Bresha has a mystic quality about it and Nautilus really gives the feel of a large fun loving city. People don't seem to realize it's a story driven game, heavily story driven in fact. The levels being linear makes it easier for the story to follow a set path.
As for the story itself, I found it engaging. Here you have 5 (then 6) individuals who are essentially exiled from society and are trying to protect the people that hate them. Each character, although somewhat cliched, is unique.
Lightning is the typical loner that warms up. Snow is a brash man who will do anything for his love. Hope is vengeful after his mother died. Vanille copes with her difficult life in what's probably not the best way, and Fang is a motherly figure who is Vanille's only true friend.
One of the most moving scenes is when Sazh confronts Vanille. The emotions in that scene are very moving, a man has to confront a friend who is revealed to have effectively murdered his son. He questions if he has anything to live for.
Then the actual gameplay. Those saying that the entire thing plays autonomously are making good use of hyperbole. You definitely could not go up to the Adamantoise or Vercingetorix and spam Auto Battle. There is a lot of strategy involved. Don't use the right people with the right Paradigms and up-to-date Crystarium? They'll wipe the floors with you. The battle system makes such fights as Barthandelus, to say the least, Epic. Not to mention the soundtrack is superb, really setting the mood for touching cutscenes or tense battles.
To conclude, I personally think Final Fantasy 13 is a good game with, most of all, an engaging plot. It is a VERY heavily story driven game. I may be omitting the bad parts, but I don't think there is anything truly bad about it, other than being a little long. But with such a story heavy game you're expected to be patient.
As a game, I think it's superb. As a Final Fantasy game? I can't say.
Please remember that these are only my views, I can't speak for other people. I realize that the game may not, and does not, appeal to everybody.