Creator002 said:
Whatislove said:
1. This is not backwards compatibility
I get what you mean. All the games are digital downloads, even the discs download a digital version, but I don't think many people care about which word is used. They can play old games on a new console. That's all that matters.
Whatislove said:
2. It will be no where near as good as you think it will be
As a member of the Preview Program, I think I can say it actually works quite well. I played ME from start to finish and it looked and played fine. Gears of War is fine too, so are all of the 360 Rare Replay games. They play as if they were on a 360. Unless you expect better, that's the highest we can aim for (considering it's a 360 emulator running on the Xbox One).
I'm sure the functionality works fine, that wasn't what I meant by not being as good as people think.
I meant that there won't be near as many games supported by the feature as there was made out to be.
Like I said, it's just another implementation of something that's been done before and it runs into the same issues, the big one being licensing; the common misconception seems to be "oh, but they'll get all the big popular ones supported!" when really how popular the game is has nothing to do with it.
Take Final Fantasy 7 Crisis Core on PSP for example, one of the consoles biggest sellers and most requested game to come to the PSN for download (on psp or vita), it will never make an appearance because of a licensing issue with the music in the game. Kingdoms hearts on the PSP is in a similar situation.
Microsoft have made a perfectly good tool but they still need to get the developers on board, and even if the developers are on board they then have to re-negotiate licensing agreements and a whole bunch of other legal crap that most developers/companies will see as a waste of time - and even if they do put in the time and effort there is no guarantee they'll come to terms to make it available through the service.
I've always had a problem with the name 'backwards compatibility' because it really couldn't be further from the truth, like you said, you have to re-download a digital version of the game anyway, it doesn't play from the disc, and it doesn't even have have compatibility with 10% of the total Xbox 360 titles, and it won't ever have anywhere near 100%.
Honestly, I'd be surprised if 300 games total make it to this service during the lifespan of the Xbox One.
Don't get me wrong, I don't hate the feature, but it was touted as something it clearly isn't, and seeing the list doesn't have a single game I'd hoped for (like any number of the JRPG exclusives Microsoft paid out the ass for) doesn't give me any confidence going forward.