Witcher 3, Command & Conquer 3, Deus Ex (the Ion Storm original), Space Marine, Batman Arkham Asylum/City, and Bayonetta.
Never did buy in the hype for Mass Effect oddly enough. I only bought the game because there was all that controversy surrounding it. But I enjoyed the game immensely nonetheless. I did like ME2, even though it felt disappointing (overall), and as for 3, the poor story made it the least enjoyable (though the game itself was fun). Hype is one of things that just makes the disappointment hurt more if the game fails.