games you consider to be art

[blackdwarf]

i disagree that all games are art! soem games just don't deserve that title. as example (first thing that comes to mind) duke nukem, do you consider that game art? hell no. and people that are saying that movies are also always art, do you consider twilight (again, first thing that comes to mind ) art? again: hell no.

but no the question: which games are art? you have to know that this differ to every person.

some games of my:
shadow of the colossus(no shit )
legend of zelda windwaker.
oblivion.(although a bit on the border)
dragon age: origins.
tales of vesperia.

and there are some games i still not sure about:
proffesor layton.
9hours 9person 9doors.
ghost trick.

and probably more, but this is enough for now.

there will be some people who will disagree with me, but that is the point with art, its for everyone different.

only because the medium is a artform, doenst mean that every 'production' of that medium is art.

 

[Hectix777]

No More Heroes 2: Desperate Struggle

prove me wrong

 

[godofgamers]

I liked Shadow of Chernobyl, but Clear Sky was just way too evil. I appreciate the challenge of a hard game, but when the opposition can snipe me with a shotgun, I start getting a bit pissed off. Clear Sky almost gave me an aneurism.

 

[Not G. Ivingname]

games that trancend the average that aspire to be something more then the usual the games that really raise the bar for all games from the indie hits to the AAAs
please leave a reason why and "because i think its neat" is not an answer

Well, under my own personal definetion of art, they ALL are art.

From Bioshock to Big Rigs, all of them.

It is just that Bioshock is high art, and Big Rigs is "we hit the bottom of the barrel and started digging" art.

 

[SageRuffin]

"because i think its neat" is not an answer

Why not? Beauty is in the eye of the beholder after all. One man's trash is another man's treasure, and all that.

I think that even something as low-brow as Duke Nukem or Dead or Alive can hold just as much artistic merit as your oft-referenced SotC, Ico, and Psychonauts, if for no other reason that graphics and character designs.

On that note, I'm not gonna give my own list of games because I almost positive that I would be attacked to no end... for no fucking reason, suffice to say that my list and your list will have very little if any overlap.

Hmm... I think I repeated myself up there. Ah well.

 

[ten.to.ten]

No one's mentioned Takeshi no Chousenjou for the Famicom? If videogames are an artform then Takeshi no Chousenjou is one brilliant piece of Dadaism.

 

[Sterling|D-Reaver]

Art (noun)
1.The expression or application of human creative skill and imagination, typically in a visual form such as painting or sculpture, producing works to be appreciated primarily for their beauty or emotional power

2. Works produced by such skill and imagination

Ect. . .
Google: Art Definition

more OT: I don't think all games actually qualify exactly but technically? perhaps. . .

My 'Game that is Art:' Machinarium pretty much just because it came to mind when I saw this thread.

 

[Fbuh]

Well, you'd have to analyze it by genre. For instance, Chrono Trigger did not set the standard for games like Grand Theft Auto, but it certainly did for other RPGs. And then it's not a question of the best game (visually, at least), but of which one best set the standard. All in all, my vote is for Pong.

 

[liquidsolid]

Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty

It is a postmodern game that gets you to question both your role as a gamer, but also to further question your role in society.

 

[Nautical Honors Society]

All games are art, just like all paintings and all movies. They might not be good, but it's still art.

My thoughts exactly.

Just because it's art doesn't mean it's good art.

 

[Nautical Honors Society]

Sorry for the double post...damn smartphone.