I have a feeling that there are some parts of each of the sides of the story that are right. Gamespy has a different side with each dev/publisher. It wouldn't surprise me if some of the servers were unpaid and probably linked to other servers for different games that were being paid for(Hence the 4 years part). It also wouldn't surprise me if part of the price hike was to account for revenue lost(on the books) for time not paid for servers.
Let slip the hounds of litigation.
Let slip the hounds of litigation.