GameStop Releases Xenoblade Chronicles Stock, Increases Price

WhiteTigerShiro

New member
Sep 26, 2008
2,366
0
0
Omegatronacles said:
Wait, it is an uncommon thing in the US for rare used games to be worth far more than retail?

That's a common practice here in Australia.
Then move to a different country if you don't like how the taxes and other costs of shipping games to your continent drives the price up.
 

Quellist

Migratory coconut
Oct 7, 2010
1,443
0
0
Arqus_Zed said:
Quellist said:
Arqus_Zed said:
I'm experiencing a malevolent sort of joy right now.

For years on end, the US market has been getting ALL the advantages: earlier releases, special compilation releases and games that never got outside of Japan and the US (Tales of ..., Metal Saga, Suikoden III, Radiata Stories, Grandia III, Devil Summoner 2, Xenosaga I & III, Arc the Lad: End of Darknes, etc.). But then the whole Operation Rainfall thing happened. We European folks finally had a stroke of luck in that Xenoblade Chronicles, The Last Story and Pandora's Tower had their European release dates confirmed at a time when they weren't even sure the games would get an American release at all. And I just sat there and watched with glee how this one trinity of titles drove a whole group of people mad, starting up a petition and calling the whole damn thing an "Operation". Christ, you guys aren't used to not getting want you want, are you?

And then this happens.

Now, I can't help but sitting here with a grin on my face, whispering: "Justice".
(Even though I realize it has very little to do with any form of justice.)
Thats a pretty nasty attitude and i'm british myself and got all games new at a reasonable price so its not sour grapes on my part.

As if all the bloody ebay resellers offering 'New, sealed' copies of the game at a disgusting markup arnt bad enough, when retailers get in on the game the people who suffer are the actual gamers.
Nasty attitude? Guilty pleasure is more like it. I am yet to meet someone who never enjoyed a little moment of schadenfreude. So yeah, just because I'm relieved that for once in this medium's run we don't have to touch the dirty end of the shit-stick, you're gonna go all "for shame" on me? Well then, good sir, I myself will state that I disapprove of you and your "holier than thou"-attitude.
Disapprove all you like. The US is such a big market anything that disrupts sales of a JRPG there hurts the chances of other JRPGs to be localized to some degree. If you want to celebrate that then be my guest but as someone who loves the Genre I wont join you
 

Roxas1359

Burn, Burn it All!
Aug 8, 2009
33,758
1
0
major_chaos said:
Those are not really good examples, considering none of them are all that rare. better examples would be things like (Amazon prices. Rounded):
Mega Man Ledgends 2: $65 used, $400 new
.Hack GU Vol 1: $60 used, $125 new
Valkyrie Profile: $70 used, $220 new
Panzer Dragoon Saga: $285 used(!) $1,500 new (!!)

Rare games being expensive is not uncommon.
You think Legends 2 is expensive take a look around for the Misadventures of Tron Bonne. To get just the disc itself with no jewel case or artwork used is usually $100, and that's the cheapest. New copies go close to $1000. It's a shame too because I would love to have the Misadventures of Tron Bonne to LP since I've done Legends 1 and 2 already.
 

piinyouri

New member
Mar 18, 2012
2,708
0
0
major_chaos said:
YES FINALY. Ran out and picked this up as soon as I found out. Between coupons and a trade in I got it for 60$ instead of the $100+ I was looking at on amazon, and now my Rainfall collection is complete.
piinyouri said:
Omegatronacles said:
Wait, it is an uncommon thing in the US for rare used games to be worth far more than retail?

That's a common practice here in Australia.
No it's not.
I could probably go get Thief Deadly Shadows, Makai Kingdoms and Final Fantasy X-2 all used for less than the price of a new $60 dollar game.
Those are not really good examples, considering none of them are all that rare. better examples would be things like (Amazon prices. Rounded):
Mega Man Ledgends 2: $65 used, $400 new
.Hack GU Vol 1: $60 used, $125 new
Valkyrie Profile: $70 used, $220 new
Panzer Dragoon Saga: $285 used(!) $1,500 new (!!)

Rare games being expensive is not uncommon.
I'm not talking about rare games, just the price of a video game being 90 bucks, rare or not.
 

Arqus_Zed

New member
Aug 12, 2009
1,181
0
0
Quellist said:
Arqus_Zed said:
Quellist said:
Arqus_Zed said:
I'm experiencing a malevolent sort of joy right now.

For years on end, the US market has been getting ALL the advantages: earlier releases, special compilation releases and games that never got outside of Japan and the US (Tales of ..., Metal Saga, Suikoden III, Radiata Stories, Grandia III, Devil Summoner 2, Xenosaga I & III, Arc the Lad: End of Darknes, etc.). But then the whole Operation Rainfall thing happened. We European folks finally had a stroke of luck in that Xenoblade Chronicles, The Last Story and Pandora's Tower had their European release dates confirmed at a time when they weren't even sure the games would get an American release at all. And I just sat there and watched with glee how this one trinity of titles drove a whole group of people mad, starting up a petition and calling the whole damn thing an "Operation". Christ, you guys aren't used to not getting want you want, are you?

And then this happens.

Now, I can't help but sitting here with a grin on my face, whispering: "Justice".
(Even though I realize it has very little to do with any form of justice.)
Thats a pretty nasty attitude and i'm british myself and got all games new at a reasonable price so its not sour grapes on my part.

As if all the bloody ebay resellers offering 'New, sealed' copies of the game at a disgusting markup arnt bad enough, when retailers get in on the game the people who suffer are the actual gamers.
Nasty attitude? Guilty pleasure is more like it. I am yet to meet someone who never enjoyed a little moment of schadenfreude. So yeah, just because I'm relieved that for once in this medium's run we don't have to touch the dirty end of the shit-stick, you're gonna go all "for shame" on me? Well then, good sir, I myself will state that I disapprove of you and your "holier than thou"-attitude.
Disapprove all you like. The US is such a big market anything that disrupts sales of a JRPG there hurts the chances of other JRPGs to be localized to some degree. If you want to celebrate that then be my guest but as someone who loves the Genre I wont join you
But that's just the thing, isn't it? These three big RPGs I'm talking about (Xenoblade Chronicles, The Last Story and Pandora's Tower) all had their European release dates confirmed while they weren't even sure they would get a US release. Yes, in the past, bad sales of certain JRPGs in the US have been a factor in some of said JRPGs not coming to Europe. However, in this instance, Nintendo Europe had chosen to localize these games, despite Nintendo America being on the fence about it. In a way, the mere fact that such a situation has prevented itself, is somewhat a sign of independence, showing that we don't have to be completely reliant on how a JRPG fares in the US before it is brought over.
 

major_chaos

Ruining videogames
Feb 3, 2011
1,314
0
0
Neronium said:
You think Legends 2 is expensive take a look around for the Misadventures of Tron Bonne. To get just the disc itself with no jewel case or artwork used is usually $100, and that's the cheapest. New copies go close to $1000. It's a shame too because I would love to have the Misadventures of Tron Bonne to LP since I've done Legends 1 and 2 already.
I remember being extremely disappointed when I first found out Misadventures of Tron Bonne is impossible to get legitimately for less than $100, it seems like such a fun quirky little title. Interestingly, it apparently doesn't play nice with emulators, so its actually also impossible to play it illegitimately, which puts it in its own class of rarity.
 

Jaden Kazega

New member
Nov 12, 2011
32
0
0
Arqus_Zed said:
Quellist said:
Arqus_Zed said:
Quellist said:
Arqus_Zed said:
I'm experiencing a malevolent sort of joy right now.

For years on end, the US market has been getting ALL the advantages: earlier releases, special compilation releases and games that never got outside of Japan and the US (Tales of ..., Metal Saga, Suikoden III, Radiata Stories, Grandia III, Devil Summoner 2, Xenosaga I & III, Arc the Lad: End of Darknes, etc.). But then the whole Operation Rainfall thing happened. We European folks finally had a stroke of luck in that Xenoblade Chronicles, The Last Story and Pandora's Tower had their European release dates confirmed at a time when they weren't even sure the games would get an American release at all. And I just sat there and watched with glee how this one trinity of titles drove a whole group of people mad, starting up a petition and calling the whole damn thing an "Operation". Christ, you guys aren't used to not getting want you want, are you?

And then this happens.

Now, I can't help but sitting here with a grin on my face, whispering: "Justice".
(Even though I realize it has very little to do with any form of justice.)
Thats a pretty nasty attitude and i'm british myself and got all games new at a reasonable price so its not sour grapes on my part.

As if all the bloody ebay resellers offering 'New, sealed' copies of the game at a disgusting markup arnt bad enough, when retailers get in on the game the people who suffer are the actual gamers.
Nasty attitude? Guilty pleasure is more like it. I am yet to meet someone who never enjoyed a little moment of schadenfreude. So yeah, just because I'm relieved that for once in this medium's run we don't have to touch the dirty end of the shit-stick, you're gonna go all "for shame" on me? Well then, good sir, I myself will state that I disapprove of you and your "holier than thou"-attitude.
Disapprove all you like. The US is such a big market anything that disrupts sales of a JRPG there hurts the chances of other JRPGs to be localized to some degree. If you want to celebrate that then be my guest but as someone who loves the Genre I wont join you
But that's just the thing, isn't it? These three big RPGs I'm talking about (Xenoblade Chronicles, The Last Story and Pandora's Tower) all had their European release dates confirmed while they weren't even sure they would get a US release. Yes, in the past, bad sales of certain JRPGs in the US have been a factor in some of said JRPGs not coming to Europe. However, in this instance, Nintendo Europe had chosen to localize these games, despite Nintendo America being on the fence about it. In a way, the mere fact that such a situation has prevented itself, is somewhat a sign of independence, showing that we don't have to be completely reliant on how a JRPG fares in the US before it is brought over.
Which translates to NA Nintendo players missing out on these games being something to feel a certain joy over because...? Anyone being cut off from games via region locking should never be something to be celebrated. I never honestly understood this attitude, whether it be some NA guy thinking it about Europe or some European guy thinking about a game not being released in say, Australia. There's just this certain elitist taste to it which, at the end of the day, doesn't quite make any sense. There is a huge difference between being glad that something came out in your own region, and being glad that a game didn't come out in someone else's region. Where exactly is the upside to this? Please, explain to me what the benefit is and why there should be a cause for celebration.
 

Golden_Ocelot

New member
Oct 28, 2011
4
0
0
Super Not Cosmo said:
Supply and demand. Honestly I applaud them this is a damn savvy business move.

Let's not kid ourselves though this isn't uncommon to see in gaming. I used to buy multiple WoW collector's editions and resell them on Ebay for four to five times what I paid for them.

When the Wii came out myself and some buddies would scout out when businesses were going to get a shipment and buy up as many as they'd sell us (sometimes it was all of them) and turn around the same day and sell a Wii with the controller attachment for right a bit less than double of what we'd pay and the few days before Christmas we started charging well over double. 99 times out of 100 they sold within hours of us listing them. Towards the end we had a list of people practically begging us to pay over twice retail value for a Wii console. We stopped a few weeks after Christmas and when we took the money out of the bank and divided it up we each walked away with about $4500 in profit.

Was it worth it freezing our balls off in sub zero whether from 3am until the doors opened in some Toys R Us parking lot in Devil's Asshole Indiana multiple times a week? That's debatable.

My point is that the value of an item is whatever someone is willing to pay for it. Right now it seems the fair value of Xenoblade Chronicles is 90 dollars. I wouldn't expect Gamestop to charge less.
Aye, there's actual Sensibility. Sir/Ma'am, I applaud you! If people don't like the price, don't buy it at that. If you absolutely must have the game and don't want to shop at gamestop.... go online and pay up to triple what they're selling it for. Evil, evil gamestop, saving you money like that and making sure inventory is available, oh, how dare they.... First listing on ebay is 195 right now. lots of reasonably comparable offers around the 80's for used. but once you buy it, it's yours. no return policy, only ebay's word that something will happen to the other people if you get ripped off...

Gamestop is a business, just like ebay. But then again, so are pawn stores, wal*marts, gas stations...

Go ahead and try to buy used gas. or try to not complain about the price of gas every time it goes up even a little. And gas is pretty much a necessity. Games aren't- they're pure luxury. This is the 2nd most expensive game i've ever seen at a gamestop. only other one was such a collectors item, i've never seen a copy of, ever again.



Tenmar said:
And this is what pissed me off when I found out that Xenoblade was going to be a GAMESTOP exclusive. Seriously how fucking much did gamestop pay for when the whole point of Operation rainfall was to get them brought to the USA and prove that the games could sell. I mean honestly Best Buy, Target, Walmart, Newegg, Tiger Direct and millions of shops that could of sold Xenoblade was cut short.
But none of those companies were willing to shell out the cash for contract like Gamestop was. You'd rather have Xenoblade be another Valkyria Chronicles 3? Never to be seen outside of Asia? Yes Operation Rainfall got Nintendo to LOOK for a company to bring it over into the states. It would have been even better if other companies had jumped on the bandwagon EARLIER that Last Story. decry gamestop all you want, the fact is you wanted this game. and you DIDN'T have to go through them to get it, NoA was selling them directly until they ran out of stock as well. Gamestop could have made it so all sales went through them only, but didn't.



***
It's seriously easy to point blame on one singular company, but where does the real fault lie? Game makers are hesitant about making games outside their home company without guaranteed sales. Look at how poorly the Xbox does in japan, to the point where the XB1 isn't even launching there initially. Nintendo had a foothold in America a long time, but Sega's consoles collapsed. Square Enix sold MILLIONS of copies of Tomb Raider, but put so much money into it still fell short of its production value. It's always a risk for a game to be made- some worse than others (Aliens: Colonial Marines, Retribution: Ride to Hell 1%), but some shining stars get overlooked (Namco X series, Metal Saga series, and ALMOST Phoenix Wright X Professor Layton).

Why would a company not want to produce a game? Not because retailers won't sell it- a company makes all their money by selling it TO retailers, like Gamestop, like Wal*Mart, NOT to the consumers- except Nintendo, but they're a special case ^^. Your money goes to big companies ordering more copies in. If the initial load of games doesn't sell out, don't expect a lot of copies to get made. Evil corporations rely on sales to get more product. Sales comes from ... dun dun duuuuun! People.

Xenoblade Chronicles is rare now because more people didn't buy it, not because Nintendo and Gamestop didn't want them to sell. Of course they wanted them to sell, it would have made MORE money- just look at Last of Us for Naughty Dog- still chugging them out, #1 best selling game in the world. How many MILLIONS of GTAV's are preordered? How many CoD games are there anymore, even? People are still buying them, doesn't matter which one. it's CoD, right?

People who want to complain about the price of a great game being high in the pre-owned market (consisting entirely of person to person sales, online bidding sites, pawn stores, and select corporations only), I ask a serious question...

Why didn't you buy it when it was brand new to start with, when it was normal price?

If you already have it, you know it's a great game, and this pricing doesn't affect you at all. Or are you upset that a friend will have to pay that to get it? Why not let them borrow it and see how great it is?

Can't afford the $90 from Gamestop? trade old stuff in. we all know they take in games and stuff. don't want to get rid of your stuff? partner up, split the cost, share the game with a good friend. Enjoy it together.

It's a game. nothing more... nothing less.
 

Roxas1359

Burn, Burn it All!
Aug 8, 2009
33,758
1
0
major_chaos said:
Neronium said:
You think Legends 2 is expensive take a look around for the Misadventures of Tron Bonne. To get just the disc itself with no jewel case or artwork used is usually $100, and that's the cheapest. New copies go close to $1000. It's a shame too because I would love to have the Misadventures of Tron Bonne to LP since I've done Legends 1 and 2 already.
I remember being extremely disappointed when I first found out Misadventures of Tron Bonne is impossible to get legitimately for less than $100, it seems like such a fun quirky little title. Interestingly, it apparently doesn't play nice with emulators, so its actually also impossible to play it illegitimately, which puts it in its own class of rarity.
I will say I had the chance at playing it. My friend let me borrow the game and I got to play the first mission, but then the disc got errors. I cleaned the disc and tried to get it to work, but still no avail. And it not working with emulators sounds like when I had tried to get the PSX2 emulator to run Klonoa 2, I ripped the ISO from my disc, mainly because the HD PVR 2 would glitch out when trying to record Klonoa 2 Lunatea's Veil. It works now, with some help from a 3rd party HDMI converter, but still.
I'm planning on saving up to eventually get the game, but what sucks is that it's also stuck in the same limbo that Earthbound was stuck in due to legal issues, otherwise it would have been released on the PSN along with Legends and Legends 2.
 

Omegatronacles

Guardian Of Forever
Oct 15, 2009
731
0
0
WhiteTigerShiro said:
Omegatronacles said:
Wait, it is an uncommon thing in the US for rare used games to be worth far more than retail?

That's a common practice here in Australia.
Then move to a different country if you don't like how the taxes and other costs of shipping games to your continent drives the price up.
Where the hell did that come from? I made absolutely no reference to taxes or shipping. I'm not even talking about the generally higher prices of software, which are currently under a government investigation because taxes and shipping do not justify the higher prices. I'm talking about the fact that rare second hand games frequently sell in store for far more than they did brand new. The original article makes this sound like it's an uncommon practice in the States.
 

Quellist

Migratory coconut
Oct 7, 2010
1,443
0
0
Arqus_Zed said:
Quellist said:
Arqus_Zed said:
Quellist said:
Arqus_Zed said:
I'm experiencing a malevolent sort of joy right now.

For years on end, the US market has been getting ALL the advantages: earlier releases, special compilation releases and games that never got outside of Japan and the US (Tales of ..., Metal Saga, Suikoden III, Radiata Stories, Grandia III, Devil Summoner 2, Xenosaga I & III, Arc the Lad: End of Darknes, etc.). But then the whole Operation Rainfall thing happened. We European folks finally had a stroke of luck in that Xenoblade Chronicles, The Last Story and Pandora's Tower had their European release dates confirmed at a time when they weren't even sure the games would get an American release at all. And I just sat there and watched with glee how this one trinity of titles drove a whole group of people mad, starting up a petition and calling the whole damn thing an "Operation". Christ, you guys aren't used to not getting want you want, are you?

And then this happens.

Now, I can't help but sitting here with a grin on my face, whispering: "Justice".
(Even though I realize it has very little to do with any form of justice.)
Thats a pretty nasty attitude and i'm british myself and got all games new at a reasonable price so its not sour grapes on my part.

As if all the bloody ebay resellers offering 'New, sealed' copies of the game at a disgusting markup arnt bad enough, when retailers get in on the game the people who suffer are the actual gamers.
Nasty attitude? Guilty pleasure is more like it. I am yet to meet someone who never enjoyed a little moment of schadenfreude. So yeah, just because I'm relieved that for once in this medium's run we don't have to touch the dirty end of the shit-stick, you're gonna go all "for shame" on me? Well then, good sir, I myself will state that I disapprove of you and your "holier than thou"-attitude.
Disapprove all you like. The US is such a big market anything that disrupts sales of a JRPG there hurts the chances of other JRPGs to be localized to some degree. If you want to celebrate that then be my guest but as someone who loves the Genre I wont join you
But that's just the thing, isn't it? These three big RPGs I'm talking about (Xenoblade Chronicles, The Last Story and Pandora's Tower) all had their European release dates confirmed while they weren't even sure they would get a US release. Yes, in the past, bad sales of certain JRPGs in the US have been a factor in some of said JRPGs not coming to Europe. However, in this instance, Nintendo Europe had chosen to localize these games, despite Nintendo America being on the fence about it. In a way, the mere fact that such a situation has prevented itself, is somewhat a sign of independence, showing that we don't have to be completely reliant on how a JRPG fares in the US before it is brought over.
Not completely no, but in general the markets are linked and the more JRPGs sold in the US the more likely we are to get more over here so personally i'll do all i can to promote their sale.
 

Caostotale

New member
Mar 15, 2010
122
0
0
When I saw this, I didn't hesitate to order myself a copy, using the GUST15 discount code and getting the used-game discount. I have no loyalty to Gamestop whatsoever, but I simultaneously have next to zero faith in the half-accountable and oftentimes sloppy used/rare games market that operates on eBay and Amazon. Too often, I've received scratched-up 'disk only, no booklet' sales that were advertised as 'very good' or 'like new'. If Gamestop is simultaneously offering an untouched new copy masquerading as a used copy, yes, it is shady, but in the simplest terms, you are buying a higher-quality product that has a much better return-policy than some Joe Schmo on Amazon who might just choose not to answer your e-mails.

Meanwhile, the entire gaming internet is already up in arms and crying foul because Gamestop is yet again failing to be the progressive-socialist gaming institution that a perfect and balanced 'arts, letters, and leisure' world would properly dictate. The way I see it, Gamestop is as predictable as any other capitalist institution and they simply had their ear to the track on this situation. I don't know the details of the game's stateside publication contracts and so on, but from day one, this title was basically screaming a loud signal that stated 'I'M GOING TO BE CRAZY RARE IN A MATTER OF MONTHS SO BUY ME NOWWWW!!!' that loads of people completely ignored, likely including no small amount of people who probably dabbled in the Operation Rainfall petition. I had wanted the game since it was new on shelves and simply penny-pinched, dithered, and focused on other stuff I was interested in until Xenoblade vanished for good. Buying it now at this new-and-improved price is certainly less than ideal, but I still feel like a smarter consumer than any number of dummies who wait in lines on Black Friday to buy new systems that lack games...or anyone who buys 'new games' at Gamestop.
 

WeepingAngels

New member
May 18, 2013
1,722
0
0
medv4380 said:
Bold move, but all Nintendo has to do is a quick port to the WiiU so that it can be purchased via eShop and their legitimate price gouging due to restricted supply is obliterated. It wouldn't even be a shotty port since most of the hardware is nearly identical architecture.
Was in a local used games shop a few weeks ago and Earthbound actually went up by $55 after the Wii U release. From $170 to $225.