I had to look where I called BSG nihilistic, and turns out I did. To refresh:
Nihilism: "The rejection of all religious and moral principles, in the belief that life is meaningless."
Existential Nihilism: "That life is without meaning, purpose, or intrinsic value."
Moral Nihilism: "There is no inherent morality, and that accepted moral values are abstractly contrived."
So, in fairness, BSG isn't nihilistic, but Vamp does point out that "nihilsitic" is used colloquially to describe dark, gritty, brooding material. That said, I think there are elements of nihilism to be found in BSG, in that:
a) The universe is a cold, uncaring place that isn't suited for life (this is more or less outright stated in season 1). That humanity managed to find a habitable star system after leaving Kobol (and likely arriving at Kobol from someplace else, given that a continuous cycle is going on), and later finds Earth, these are just exceptions to the rule. Habitable planets are few and far between.
b) As stated, humanity seems to be in a cycle of creation and destruction, fated to tread the same path over and over until they manage to get lucky. The ending leaves it up to you whether humanity on Earth will transcend this or will have its own AI rebellion. "God" in the series apparently has a plan for humanity, but it's a plan that involves a lot of trial and error.
Nihilism: "The rejection of all religious and moral principles, in the belief that life is meaningless."
Existential Nihilism: "That life is without meaning, purpose, or intrinsic value."
Moral Nihilism: "There is no inherent morality, and that accepted moral values are abstractly contrived."
So, in fairness, BSG isn't nihilistic, but Vamp does point out that "nihilsitic" is used colloquially to describe dark, gritty, brooding material. That said, I think there are elements of nihilism to be found in BSG, in that:
a) The universe is a cold, uncaring place that isn't suited for life (this is more or less outright stated in season 1). That humanity managed to find a habitable star system after leaving Kobol (and likely arriving at Kobol from someplace else, given that a continuous cycle is going on), and later finds Earth, these are just exceptions to the rule. Habitable planets are few and far between.
b) As stated, humanity seems to be in a cycle of creation and destruction, fated to tread the same path over and over until they manage to get lucky. The ending leaves it up to you whether humanity on Earth will transcend this or will have its own AI rebellion. "God" in the series apparently has a plan for humanity, but it's a plan that involves a lot of trial and error.