Eldritch Warlord said:
Mersadeon said:
I will love to play Hearthstone, but I worry about longevity - there aren't a lot of cards. I'm a Magic: The Gathering player. I'm used to thousands to build fun casual decks.
I like the strategic thinking that comes from the relatively simple and smooth rules in Hearthstone, but I think I will always yearn for those crazy, rule-heavy MTG late-game hijinks. Seriously, once everyone is in some way immortal, or can't be attacked, or has some incredible big meanie on the field or gains 50 lifepoints per turn and you have to really think about combining your cards to get through - that's what I love. Hearthstone has that, but isn't quite as crazy.
The cards seem a bit too... vanilla. Pretty much the only really weird cards are legendaries, and most of the really weird legendaries are abysmal in comparison to vanilla drops.
That sort of stuff will come with time. MtG is 20 years old now and Hearthstone is still in Beta. Blizzard will keep adding more cards because after all they like Wizards of the Coast really want you buying expansion packs.
Yep. Guarantee in about a year after release we'll be seeing new class types (Death Knight?), or maybe new heroes to be your avatar (Magni BronzeBeard for Warriors?).
Constructed Hearthstone players have access to a total of 381(?) cards. Less, if you only consider the card pool available to a single class.
Type 2 (read: only the two most recently released blocks and the only fair comparison) constructed Magic the Gathering players have access to a total of 1346 cards plus the basic set of 200 odd cards. This does drop down by 400 cards when a new block is released and the old block fazes out of the tournament legal type 2, but that still leaves you with about
triple the cards that Hearthstone has access to.
Even scarier is that MtG releases a new set
every four months. With three sets in each block, that means a new block every year.
Don't get me wrong, I love Hearthstone. I watch streams very regularly of the lucky few who got invites and I think the rules are a lot more elegant than MtG's but well... blizzard's track record with new content is absolutely abysmal. If they keep the same rate of new content in Hearthstone as they do in their other games, which is a non-trivial "if", since card-games are not pc games, but if they keep their same, abysmally slow content schedule then the game will be fairly shortlived.
Basically, Blizzard will need to release a new hero four times a year to offer the same variety in options as MtG. I think it unlikely that they will, but I'm hoping they do.