grigjd3 said:
Hagi said:
You've not been reading my posts have you... Here, I'll quote one for you:
Actually, I have. The point is, people will attempt to keep living a normal life no matter what is going on. It's not like Pearl Harbor occurred and soldiers stopped going to strip clubs until May of 1945 (that would be silly to believe). Rather, with the increase in numbers of soldiers, strip clubs flourished during that time. Even while fighting in Europe, some soldiers managed to find time to have sex with women in France. It's not silly, it's human. All the little distractions are human. People just function better when they have some sense of normalcy. This is simply human - which is not nearly so silly as a fleet of evil space ships destroying advanced life on an arbitrary though clearly defined frequency due to the philosophical ramblings of some space-station/illusory boy/ridiculous and unnecessary plot device. The attempt at everyday life - that's a common human trait. The over the top plot based on some game designer's sad attempt at wrapping up weak loose-ends - that's silly.
Except this is not normal life.
This is a guy on a mission that has an amazing sense of duty.
It's the equivalent of a cop getting a call that there's currently a bank heist in progress and stopping at the bakery on the way there. A soldier on guard duty in a warzone taking half an hour off to watch a funny TV episode. I'm sure some of them even do that, but not those with Shepard's personality.
Again and again in ME3 it's underlined how life isn't normal anymore. Not for anyone. There's countless refugees, constant Reaper attacks, terrorist strikes by Cerberus etc. And we're supposed to believe that a man, on whose minds are constantly the thousands of people dying back on Earth and all over the galaxy and whose constantly shown extreme willpower and sense of duty is going to take a few hours off to visit a strip club?
And you can keep on mentioning the silliness of the plot as much as you like, I even agree, but it doesn't magically make the rest not silly. One thing being silly doesn't somehow make other things perfectly normal.
The thing isn't that some other soldier is doing these things, they very well might have. The point is that Shepard is doing them and seeming to suffer from memory loss as he goes from stressing the urgency of his mission to relaxing at the local strip club the next moment. That's what's silly. In that exact context. Not in some other context, with some other person.
This context, a man we know would go to any length to do what he sees as his duty talking to his team mates about how he worries about the millions of lives lost every day, how there's no time to spare and action must be taken now before it's too late before embarking on whatever pointless side-mission's in the game or visiting a pointless strip club. That's silly and out of character.