How Cherry City Comic Con Created a Cosplay Crisis Before First Day

Mezahmay

New member
Dec 11, 2013
517
0
0
So, is there a trend in various relatively-unknown entities garnering extremely negative press for attention these days or is that just my inner conspiracy theorist speaking up? Also, is the amount of sexual harassment in communities actually rising, or is it just being reported on more as the internet gives more and more people an outlet to make these instances known? That's what I'd like to know.
 

Winnosh

New member
Sep 23, 2010
492
0
0
Mezahmay said:
So, is there a trend in various relatively-unknown entities garnering extremely negative press for attention these days or is that just my inner conspiracy theorist speaking up? Also, is the amount of sexual harassment in communities actually rising, or is it just being reported on more as the internet gives more and more people an outlet to make these instances known? That's what I'd like to know.
It's gone down a whole lot. Trust me. It used to be bad enough to simply not go to conventions without chaperones. It's just a lot more public now because of internet coverage.
 

Mezahmay

New member
Dec 11, 2013
517
0
0
Winnosh said:
It's gone down a whole lot. Trust me. It used to be bad enough to simply not go to conventions without chaperones. It's just a lot more public now because of internet coverage.
I figured as much. It seemed more likely to me that increased reporting of sexual harassment by concerned, vocal individuals or groups than the community itself getting worse. I would not put it past a community largely held together through the internet to get more exclusive over time, but I did not get that impression from conventions. In real life, the anonymity goes away and forces people to behave themselves more than they would through a forum or comments section.
 

Winnosh

New member
Sep 23, 2010
492
0
0
Mezahmay said:
Winnosh said:
It's gone down a whole lot. Trust me. It used to be bad enough to simply not go to conventions without chaperones. It's just a lot more public now because of internet coverage.
I figured as much. It seemed more likely to me that increased reporting of sexual harassment by concerned, vocal individuals or groups than the community itself getting worse. I would not put it past a community largely held together through the internet to get more exclusive over time, but I did not get that impression from conventions. In real life, the anonymity goes away and forces people to behave themselves more than they would through a forum or comments section.
Convention promoters a lot of times still feel they need something sexy to draw in people when just as many guys are interested in good MALE cosplay as they are the sexy ladies. That's a mentality that needs to change.
 

Dragonbums

Indulge in it's whiffy sensation
May 9, 2013
3,307
0
0
Kahani said:
Seriously? People wearing, at worst, about the same as most people at a beach or swimming pool, is somehow not family friendly? What the hell is wrong with some people that they're so terrified of a bit of skin?

If your fine with taking your kid out to a con with a decent amount of sexually provocative cosplayers than fine by me. But don't expect a good majority of parents to be fine with that.
 

Dragonbums

Indulge in it's whiffy sensation
May 9, 2013
3,307
0
0
MinionJoe said:
Instead, the guy panicked, drew the ire of feminist groups, and this is the result.

I'm definitely siding with Thunderf00t's general opinion on the this occurrence.
Really? You just stated that he could of simply said "We will try to find more male cosplayers but for now this is all we have"

The issue then really started to blow up when the guy had the audacity to make public a private email of said dissatisfied customer who simply asked for a refund because she didn't appreciate the way she was talked to.

I actually find it funny that it's still feminist ire when the women in question was asking for more male representation in the cosplay group photos. Also note that their wear had nothing to do with it either.
 

Dragonbums

Indulge in it's whiffy sensation
May 9, 2013
3,307
0
0
MinionJoe said:
Dragonbums said:
I actually find it funny that it's still feminist ire when the women in question was asking for more male representation in the cosplay group photos. Also note that their wear had nothing to do with it either.
I find it funny that when a new convention organizer completely botches a customer inquiry he's then immediately labelled as "sexist" by internet activists because the customer in question happened to be a woman.
Except that he started it first when he then went on to say "Start a sexy men's cosplay club" to one of the customers when the women in question didn't even bring up the sexiness of the male cosplayers and that obviously spiraled into what it is now.

This is not to mention that he put her PM on his public facebook page and various people from his friend's list started calling her names like Crazy ***** and all sorts of fun hat stuff.
 

Kahani

New member
May 25, 2011
927
0
0
Dragonbums said:
Kahani said:
Seriously? People wearing, at worst, about the same as most people at a beach or swimming pool, is somehow not family friendly? What the hell is wrong with some people that they're so terrified of a bit of skin?
If your fine with taking your kid out to a con with a decent amount of sexually provocative cosplayers than fine by me. But don't expect a good majority of parents to be fine with that.
You appear to have missed the important point - why the hell not? Are parents terrified of taking their children to the beach because they might see someone in a bikini? If not, what exactly is so bad about seeing people who are almost all wearing significantly more than that?
 

Dragonbums

Indulge in it's whiffy sensation
May 9, 2013
3,307
0
0
Kahani said:
Dragonbums said:
Kahani said:
Seriously? People wearing, at worst, about the same as most people at a beach or swimming pool, is somehow not family friendly? What the hell is wrong with some people that they're so terrified of a bit of skin?
If your fine with taking your kid out to a con with a decent amount of sexually provocative cosplayers than fine by me. But don't expect a good majority of parents to be fine with that.
You appear to have missed the important point - why the hell not? Are parents terrified of taking their children to the beach because they might see someone in a bikini? If not, what exactly is so bad about seeing people who are almost all wearing significantly more than that?
Because at that point the bikini has been normalized as regular swim wear. Granted parents also have the choice of going there where there aren't many people around, or they can isolate themselves to a private part of the beach where the chances of running into those people are at minimum. Not to mention most beaches don't advertise themselves as family friendly.

However this convention is advertising itself as a family friendly convention. Things like that entails clothing that is not provocative or sensual. And certainly doesn't really include scantily clad cosplayers.
 

JoshuaMadoc

New member
Sep 3, 2008
165
0
0
Situations like this make me feel that I'm at the mercy of Tumblr, or, more relevantly, feminist groups I'd have the misfortune in bumping into.

Post something lewd? Feminists want my blood.

Post something practical? Nerds want my blood.

Post something practically lewd? No one gives a shit.
 

Dragonbums

Indulge in it's whiffy sensation
May 9, 2013
3,307
0
0
MinionJoe said:
After the customer commented "you'd think only women cos-play" despite there being photos of men cosplayers on the site.
Which she literally addressed in the next post that the ratio of male to female cosplayers was heavily skewed to the female side than the males. You even have a male cosplayer on here talking about how sad it is seeing as how they work just as hard on cosplay as the women and unless it's professional level quality they almost never get featured.

Organizer then draws some weird conclusions and feels the need to state that "attractiveness was not a criteria" before posting the "cos-plays".
Which is entirely his fault because as you just stated the women in question never brought up the attractiveness of the cosplayers in the first place.

Customer then draws equally weird conclusions about the convention (website?) being a "mens club page".
Not exactly. Since the OP stated that attractiveness may have been one of the reasons why there were more female cosplayers in the group than male cosplayers it wouldn't be unlikely to detract that the convention is more catered towards men for the eye candy grab.

It's clearly an issue of failure to communicate and each side having unfounded assumptions about each other.

Doesn't mean either side is "sexist", especially not just because the other side claims so.
No it doesn't. But you can't deny the situation would never of blown up like it did had the man had the decency to not post a private message politely asking for a refund due to the way she was treated on his public Facebook profile for his friends to tear her apart. An incident that caught the attention of another user who is very well known within the feminist community.
 

Weaver

Overcaffeinated
Apr 28, 2008
8,977
0
0
As someone who goes to conventions it really does seem like 75% of cosplayers are women from what I can tell; and a good 50% of them are dressed in things people wouldn't consider "family friendly". Especially since it's legal for women to go topless in public here.
 

RossaLincoln

New member
Feb 4, 2014
738
0
0
Mezahmay said:
So, is there a trend in various relatively-unknown entities garnering extremely negative press for attention these days or is that just my inner conspiracy theorist speaking up? Also, is the amount of sexual harassment in communities actually rising, or is it just being reported on more as the internet gives more and more people an outlet to make these instances known? That's what I'd like to know.
I think it's a matter of people not remaining silent about it any longer. Similar to how, when sexual harassment became something people talked about publicly. It's not that all of a sudden everyone in the workplace got seriously harrassy, it's that there'd always been this big problem but now people were finally calling it out. The increased attention can make it seem like it's getting worse, but it's actually getting better, if that makes sense, even though, of course, it's still a problem.
 

Kahani

New member
May 25, 2011
927
0
0
Dragonbums said:
However this convention is advertising itself as a family friendly convention. Things like that entails clothing that is not provocative or sensual. And certainly doesn't really include scantily clad cosplayers.
You're still not answering the question - why not? What exactly do you find so terrible about a bit of skin, in particular those bits of skin that are entirely legal to show and frequently seen in many public areas, that you think children should be prevented from seeing it at all costs? The idea that a few skimpy costumes mean a place is suddenly not appropriate for families at all is utterly ridiculous.