Guy from the 80 said:
Cheers mr.evil.
May I ask if you could name the names of these softwares?
AVS Video Recorder is what I use with my device (a SIIG-branded Somagic Easycap. Piece of shit, don't buy it unless you just want something very basic). It came with this program called Honestech VHS to DVD, which pretty much sucks. Few features and prone to crashing.
I've
attempted to use VirtualDub but it lagged like hell, possibly due to the device having like no processing power of its own.
Blaze Media Pro pulled video from the device, but not audio (obviously meant for higher-end capping devices, which actually lack audio inputs, requiring you to plug audio into your soundcard, but that introduces the problem of possible a/v sync issues).
IIRC, Roxio Creator wasn't compatible with the device at all, wouldn't even pick it up. Or maybe that was Ulead.
As you can probably tell, a lot depends on the device itself. If you get a
good device (which'll probably have "Hauppage" in the name and run you $60-100+, as opposed to my $15 piece of crap) you'll have a greater choice of software that works with it, and it might even encode the video for you on-the-fly, which will save you time and diskspace. My device for example only produces basic MPEG-2 (video and audio)--a one hour recording will be roughly 1.5GB, which I then encode to MP4 with handbrake. Fortunately handbrake is damn fast, encoding an hour recording in about 5 minutes. Other encoding software (gui stuff) can take 15-20 mins for the same.
Of course, a lot also depends on what the source of the video is and how often you intend to actually do this. It's probably not worth bothering with anything fancy if you're just ripping some old VHS tapes, for example. Depends how much you value the video. I keep saying my device is crap but it works for what I use it for, high quality isn't necessary. I will however suggest that if you go with a cheapo, be sure your computer has the horsepower for it, because it'll be doing
all the work. My laptop with a 2GHz dual core (and a high/mid-range nvidia graphics chip) isn't beefy enough to reliably record without dropping frames using my device + AVS. And even my 2.4GHz
quad core desktop gets noticeably bogged down with it. (AVS may be part of the problem too, it doesn't seem to be very efficient)