If you got a badgemaker..

[Fniff]

What badges would you make?

Smiley face...With blood.. (a warehouse full of cookies for the reference.)

 

[Legion]

...Watchmen?

Do you mean a real-life badge maker or an Escapist badge?

 

[TheNumber1Zero]

if anyone says anything with inspector at he end,I will hit them

I'd go with a white spade with a black background

 

[jonnopon3000]

What badges would you make?

Smiley face...With blood.. (a warehouse full of cookies for the reference.)

Watchmen. Duh.

I do not have any idea what badge I would make...I accidently left my crazy hat at my mum's

 

[El Poncho]

Marios face? or anything among the sorts, or a badge sayings, its-a me Mario.

 

[Turtleboy1017]

Badgemaker badgemaker make me a badge...

A Power badge like that game that Yahtzee reviewed...

TWEWY?

 

[Fniff]

I mean badge as in "I have a badge on my hat"

...Watchmen?

No! Charlie Chaplin!

 

[Hazy]

Smiley face...With blood.. (a warehouse full of cookies for the reference.)

Come on man, make it obscure!
Too easy :3 'Tis zee Watchmen.

I would make A badge of John Stossel [http://www.yesatyale.org/images/speakers/JohnStossel.jpg] giving a thumbs up.
Why would I? Well... why woulden't I!?

And a side note: The epicness emanating from his mustache is unrivaled.