Andrew Bohan said:
Isn't it a little bit down to your definition though? I mean I'm with you in as much as it's not black and white. I'm just talking about an annoyance at the ideal of people wearing the stuff etc who have no interest in them or idea about them. Honestly I just think it's retarded to do these things because people want you to. i'm more commenting on conformism than stealing a hobby. I have no problem with people gaming. Perhaps I didn't express that in agreeing with the OP but that was what I meant personally. I don't really care who games. More diversity the better. I just feel iritated when I see people stand behind banners they have no idea of the origins/representations of.
It is a little annoying when it's political or such, but in entertainment I honestly don't care. The important thing to remember about gamers is that it's only the real freakers you can identify by eye, there's no reason those hipsters can't have been playing games since before you were born and just have been delighted to finally see some cool shirts on sale.
No, no they probably aren't as in to gaming as us but we probably won't ever really know. I just don't think we should work on the assumption that they aren't really gamers because they're not stereotypical nerds. It's not enough to insist that they play something other than FPS, an FPS is as much a game as any other and we each have our pet genres (RTS man here) but I think a lot of the resentment is that they haven't had to suffer ridicule. It seems a lot of people view ridicule and ostracism as a kind of entry ritual into being a gamer, but that ostracism had nothing to do with gaming. I didn't discover gaming as a method of escape, I found it as a form of fun and dived in headlong with my mates!
Gamers seem to want others near them but also seek to rive them away.
Plus as a closing thought, bear in mind that you hardly need to be in the scene to recognise Space Invaders, Mario or a Pacman ghost. I'm willing to bet they've played those before.
Tl;dr: I don't think we should be telling them that they're not gamers based on how they look, it seems hypocritical to exclude people and complain that no one understands us.