mynameissqrat said:
Bah, considering we don't know what was actully entered in the contest It's hard to say. Plus we don't know how many people entered either. All we know is some of the peoples work who have been kind enough to submit a sample of something simmular. Besides, I liked the second comic better.
I enjoyed the second comic more, too. While the first one is actually pretty inclusive in terms of humour, you could substitute so many people from videogames or otherwise into the first one that it actually comes across as a little generic to me. (just in terms of humour)
The second is more the kind of nuanced, yet humorous insight that you find in Penny Arcade. And while people may go "Bah!" whenever someone mentions Penny Arcade, their format is powerful when it's executed correctly. Dropping iconic characters into surprising real-world scenarios in order to make an observation on the game rather than an observation on Real Life&trade is part of what Tycho and Gabe do best.
The second strip is all kinds of magnificent from that aspect (in my opinion, anyway) and has the style to back it up. How many other pathologically dour 'badass' characters could you chuck in there? First up for me would be post-Sands of Time Prince (i.e. of Persia
).
As to the contest being settled already... well, I hope that's not case. I'm sure many people would like to think they still have a fighting chance. But screw those losers -- go Team Me, baby!