pokemon can fall in a ditch and die. i stopped liking around the ruby/sapphire era when i put like 50 hours into a sapphire game and realized that it was basically grinding, which sucks. i did get pearl version (i usually get the second, less popular version) and i played through to right before the pokemon league place before i decided i didnt care anymore. and then theres the thought of having to see, and god forbid, own at some point all five freaking hundred pokemon. im sorry, but i prefer action over turn based combat, and im not that dedicated either. also, their all pretty much exactly the same in terms of story and gameplay. even some new pokemon are basically old pokemon with new names.
now that i think about it, the only reason it gets a free ride is because it was once popular, and can get away with sucking. sonic the hedgehog did this also. final fantasy aslo does this, though i can say they improved when they switched to real time action combat rather then that turn based garbage. but i still cant say i really like it.