Is this racist, does my teacher have a right to punish me for this?

Andothul

New member
Feb 11, 2010
294
0
0
Hell no. I'm a black male and i rarely find Black women attractive although its most likely because of my upbringing.

If your teacher was gonna be mad at you for anything it should be for generalizing. Not every black woman looks the same and by saying you don't find black women attractive it sounds like you're saying that they all look similiar.
 

JediMB

New member
Oct 25, 2008
3,094
0
0
If a skin color preference is racist, then so is a hair color preference, or a preference for any other genetically inherited traits.

Because... the thing is? Humanity doesn't actually have any sub-races. Racism is simply the judging of people based on inherited physical characteristics.

And you're not judging anyone. You're just saying what you're attracted to, and you can't control that any more than you can control your skin, hair or eye color. (Okay, so there's tanning and dying for skin and hair color respectively, but neither is permanent. :p)
 

Loves2spooge

New member
Apr 13, 2009
397
0
0
No, if it's in relation to physical attributes then it's not racist. As far as I'm concerned, it's like saying you prefer people with pale skin rather than tanned skin.
 

SodaDew

New member
Sep 28, 2009
417
0
0
Its not racist, your teacher is just (a idiot) worried about being sued or something.
 

Abengoshis

New member
Aug 12, 2009
626
0
0
PC trying to change our base sexual urges? Oh god now I'm scared. What has society become! xD

Your teacher is an idiot. Skin colour is a phenotype due to a combination of different alleles, just as eye colour is.
 

Aerowaves

New member
Sep 10, 2009
235
0
0
Kneejerk, shallow response. Your teacher should at least have given you a fair hearing.

I'm not a racist but I find white girls (on the whole) more attractive and black girls hardly ever (although Freda Agyeman is pretty hot).

Although come to think of it the way the question was framed does leave room for a kind of exclusive interpretation, so maybe just talk to her and say you answered it in terms of what you tend to find attractive rather than what you demand from a prospective mate.
 

MasterOfWorlds

New member
Oct 1, 2010
1,890
0
0
renegade7 said:
And also, it's not like I'd turn down a girl just because of her skin color, to me it's just one trait that I notice, and there are many more (saying nothing of intellectual and personality traits).
I'm sure this has been quoted a time or two, but I'd hope you'd notice their skin. It's sort of all over them, and if you didn't at least take some sort of note, it would be a little odd.

That aside, no, I don't consider it racist, but apparently being a white male in the southern US automatically makes me a gun toting, ultra-conservative, Bible thumping, mud trucking, camo wearing redneck who scopes out chicks at the family reunion. Oh, and racist too.

It's rediculous that you'd get in trouble for something like that, and I think that you should bring it to the attention of your parents and the school faculty. If anything, it's racist against you (I'm going out on a limb here and assuming you're white) for simply stating that you like people like you.

One of the things that greatly amuses me is that people don't realize that people tend to group things in groups of like and unlike, and the fact is that most black people are going to hang around mostly black people, and more white people are going to hang around mostly white people. It's not racist in and of itself, it's simply that they're like you, so you chill with them. Think about it. Most of your friends are probably your race, with a smattering of people from other races. It's pretty much how things work.
 

Biosophilogical

New member
Jul 8, 2009
3,264
0
0
Point out to her that race is a purely social construct, go grab some first year students from the anthropology department if you need help explaining it (honestly, first year anthropology students should be well-informed enough). She may as well call you racist for your preference of hair colour, or eye colour, or the shapes and sizes of facial features for all it is worth.

Alternatively, you could do your paper on how it is not wrong to discriminate on superficial characteristics when those superficial characteristics are the ones that count. It's a terrible tragedy to refuse someone a regular job based upon their skin colour (or eye colour, sex, gender, sexuality, etc), but if you are looking for an employee/sexual partner/actor[footnote]To some extent this can be worked around with make-up and contact lenses and stuff, but if they have a naked scene in a live theatre performance, there isn't all that much you can do to make a woman look like a man (or vice versa)[/footnote]/whatever that has superficial requirements, than discriminating someone because they don't meet those requirements is entirely understandable. I mean, would you think it is wrong to not hire someone for an office job because they can't work a computer? It is a requirement of the role.
 

docSpitfire

New member
Jun 13, 2011
110
0
0
renegade7 said:
Anyway, she didn't even give me a chance to explain what I meant by that, and wouldn't hear a word of it when I tried. Now I have to write a paper about racial tolerance. Is this right? Am I a racist, just for finding one skin color more physically appealing than the others?
You are absolutely in the right as the situation you described in the OP (technically the way it was worded COULD have meant something racist, but I take you at your word since skin color is a pretty significant aspect of physical appearance and the rest of your post wasn't laced with ignorant racial remarks as you explained your side...)

That being said, I feel that writing this paper in order to avoid trouble will more or less cement you as "the racist student" in your teacher's eyes because it is an admission that you were wrong. I would take this up with administration at the school. If your school's administration is worth even half their salary you will be given a chance to explain your side whether she sends you or not, however there are many significant advantages to resolving this by approaching them yourself before you get sent to the principle's (or whoever at your school is in charge of discipline) office.
 

The Random One

New member
May 29, 2008
3,310
0
0
sms_117b said:
I call BS on your teacher, do a paper on the difference between racial tolerance and personal preference, your teacher should take the hint.
That's what I'd do. ;-)
 

emeraldrafael

New member
Jul 17, 2010
8,589
0
0
renegade7 said:
...

EDIT/UPDATE: Okay, so the term 'colored people' comes off as racist. Just a poor choice of words on my part, sorry. I'd actually been told it was the politically correct term.
no it doesnt. What do you think the CP stands for in the NAACP? If some coloured person wants to get pissed at you for calling them a coloured person, then just tell them the organization needs to change its name. My grandfather still calls black people coloured (except the girls I dated when they were around and it bothered them), and he always said his father would call them a dark person and have no negative racial meaning to it.

OT: I trust anyone else who wrote a certain skin colour had to write a paper too? cause Im not going to lie, I'd write that if a girl was black it would... well, not a deal maker, but I've been finding myself gravitating more to the colour since dating a black girl. since dating her, i've dated 1 asian girl, 2 black girls, at one point there was an off and on thing with a native american girl, and a white girl.
 

Moosejaw

New member
Oct 11, 2010
127
0
0
Everybody discriminates everybody else for SOME reason, a lot of them surely by traits they have no control over, and no amount of anything will ever kick that out of the human race. People tend to like people who are like them and are afraid of those who aren't.
 

Dr Snakeman

New member
Apr 2, 2010
1,611
0
0
What she did is totally messed up. Your taste in women is none of her damn business, and it most certainly isn't racist. Heck, if not being particularly attracted to black girls is racist, then I must be racist, too.

Also...
YawningAngel said:
Honestly, even if you ARE racist, merely BEING racist is not a crime. There is no law saying you can't hate black people, nor should there be. ACTING on the fact that you hate a particular group is an issue, but just thinking something can hardly be held against you.
This guy speaks the truth. If you are racist, I can't punish you for that belief. Sure, I can hate your guts, but you can't punish a thought crime.
 
Mar 28, 2011
427
0
0
I've had similar said to me before simply because i generally don't find women of an african/caribbian descent attractive. I have nothing against them at all, they just don't float my boat the way other race types do. For instance; I'm white and i have a major thing for japanese/chinese women. Doesn't mean i don't like white women,(My wife-to-be is white.)just that i find some races more aesthetically pleasing than others.
 

Callate

New member
Dec 5, 2008
5,118
0
0
That's a not-uncontroversial question to be asking in the first place. If the teacher isn't ready to accept honest, personal answers to the question, regardless of whether she finds those answers offensive, she shouldn't be asking the question.
 

Th37thTrump3t

New member
Nov 12, 2009
882
0
0
Not to be devil's advocate or anything, but sometimes it's best to just omit certain things. The best thing for you to do is just accept the punishment and move on.
 

captainordo

New member
Mar 28, 2009
102
0
0
doomspore98 said:
Stromtrooper said:
No, what you describe is not racist. Though in my attempt to pick a fight, I notice you use the description "colored people". That term strikes me as a bit racist. Just saying.
While I don't think your racist I agree that the term "colored people" is a bit racist
Colored People is just a older term.
It is rarely used today, but it is used in the NAACP (National Association for the Advancement of Colored People)
 

mega48man

New member
Mar 12, 2009
638
0
0
it's not racist, it's just preference. that's why no watches porn of fat black chicks, which is sadly the only porn of black chicks.

no seriously, every porn star....is either white, latino, or american asian (or some cases japanese). the one time there's a black porn star is where she looks almost like rihanna or beyonce.
 

attackshark

New member
Nov 16, 2010
248
0
0
it's not racist.

further more you shouldn't be writing any paper about it.

thirdly, what business of your teacher's if you're racist or not?